MS/Art8/2018/D1-B/Germany/NE Atlantic: Greater North Sea — Marine Information System for Europe

Member State report / Art8 / 2018 / D1-B / Germany / NE Atlantic: Greater North Sea

Report type	Member State report to Commission
MSFD Article	Art. 8 Initial assessment (and Art. 17 updates)
Report due	2018-10-15
GES Descriptor	D1 Birds
Member State	Germany
Region/subregion	NE Atlantic: Greater North Sea
Reported by	Bundesministerium für Umwelt, Naturschutz und nukleare Sicherheit
Report date	2020-02-17
Report access	DE_ART8_GES.xml

Deutsche Nordsee (ANSDE_MS)

Simplified table

GES component	D1-B
Feature	Benthic-feeding birds											Grazing birds																			Pelagic-feeding birds																																									Surface-feeding birds																																																																Wading birds
Element	Melanitta nigra					Somateria mollissima						Anas acuta				Anas clypeata				Anas penelope				Anas platyrhynchos				Branta bernicla			Alca torda					Fratercula arctica				Gavia arctica				Gavia stellata				Mergus serrator						Morus bassanus						Phalacrocorax carbo						Uria aalge						Fulmarus glacialis						Hydrocoloeus minutus			Larus argentatus							Larus canus							Larus fuscus graellsii						Larus marinus							Larus melanocephalus				Larus ridibundus						Rissa tridactyla						Stercorarius parasiticus			Stercorarius pomarinus			Stercorarius skua			Sterna hirundo					Sterna paradisaea					Sterna sandvicensis						Sternula albifrons					Arenaria interpres				Calidris alba			Calidris alpina				Calidris canutus			Calidris maritima			Charadrius alexandrinus					Charadrius hiaticula					Haematopus ostralegus					Limosa lapponica			Limosa limosa					Numenius arquata					Numenius phaeopus			Platalea leucorodia					Pluvialis apricaria			Pluvialis squatarola			Recurvirostra avosetta					Tadorna tadorna					Tringa erythropus			Tringa nebularia			Tringa totanus					Vanellus vanellus
Element code	137073					137074						158939				158941				159168				148791				159175			137128					137131				137186				137188				159098						148776						137179						137133						137195						567449			137138							137141							148796						137146							137147				137149						137156						137172			137173			137174			137162					137165					137166						567480					147431				159084			159047				147433			159052			212611					212619					147436					159034			159035					159037					159040			416678					159135			159137			212721					232042					159029			158968			158970					159142
Element code source	Species (D1) http://www.marinespecies.org/					Species (D1) http://www.marinespecies.org/						Species (D1) http://www.marinespecies.org/				Species (D1) http://www.marinespecies.org/				Species (D1) http://www.marinespecies.org/				Species (D1) http://www.marinespecies.org/				Species (D1) http://www.marinespecies.org/			Species (D1) http://www.marinespecies.org/					Species (D1) http://www.marinespecies.org/				Species (D1) http://www.marinespecies.org/				Species (D1) http://www.marinespecies.org/				Species (D1) http://www.marinespecies.org/						Species (D1) http://www.marinespecies.org/						Species (D1) http://www.marinespecies.org/						Species (D1) http://www.marinespecies.org/						Species (D1) http://www.marinespecies.org/						Species (D1) http://www.marinespecies.org/			Species (D1) http://www.marinespecies.org/							Species (D1) http://www.marinespecies.org/							Species (D1) http://www.marinespecies.org/						Species (D1) http://www.marinespecies.org/							Species (D1) http://www.marinespecies.org/				Species (D1) http://www.marinespecies.org/						Species (D1) http://www.marinespecies.org/						Species (D1) http://www.marinespecies.org/			Species (D1) http://www.marinespecies.org/			Species (D1) http://www.marinespecies.org/			Species (D1) http://www.marinespecies.org/					Species (D1) http://www.marinespecies.org/					Species (D1) http://www.marinespecies.org/						Species (D1) http://www.marinespecies.org/					Species (D1) http://www.marinespecies.org/				Species (D1) http://www.marinespecies.org/			Species (D1) http://www.marinespecies.org/				Species (D1) http://www.marinespecies.org/			Species (D1) http://www.marinespecies.org/			Species (D1) http://www.marinespecies.org/					Species (D1) http://www.marinespecies.org/					Species (D1) http://www.marinespecies.org/					Species (D1) http://www.marinespecies.org/			Species (D1) http://www.marinespecies.org/					Species (D1) http://www.marinespecies.org/					Species (D1) http://www.marinespecies.org/			Species (D1) http://www.marinespecies.org/					Species (D1) http://www.marinespecies.org/			Species (D1) http://www.marinespecies.org/			Species (D1) http://www.marinespecies.org/					Species (D1) http://www.marinespecies.org/					Species (D1) http://www.marinespecies.org/			Species (D1) http://www.marinespecies.org/			Species (D1) http://www.marinespecies.org/					Species (D1) http://www.marinespecies.org/
Element 2
Element 2 code
Element 2 code source
Element source	EU					EU						EU				EU				EU				EU				EU			EU					EU				EU				EU				EU						EU						EU						EU						EU						EU			EU							EU							EU						EU							EU				EU						EU						EU			EU			EU			EU					EU					EU						EU					EU				EU			EU				EU			EU			EU					EU					EU					EU			EU					EU					EU			EU					EU			EU			EU					EU					EU			EU			EU					EU
Criterion	D1C1	D1C2		D1C4	D1C5	D1C1	D1C2		D1C3	D1C4	D1C5	D1C2	D1C3	D1C4	D1C5	D1C2	D1C3	D1C4	D1C5	D1C2	D1C3	D1C4	D1C5	D1C2	D1C3	D1C4	D1C5	D1C2	D1C4	D1C5	D1C1	D1C2	D1C3	D1C4	D1C5	D1C1	D1C2	D1C4	D1C5	D1C1	D1C2	D1C4	D1C5	D1C1	D1C2	D1C4	D1C5	D1C1	D1C2		D1C3	D1C4	D1C5	D1C1	D1C2		D1C3	D1C4	D1C5	D1C1	D1C2		D1C3	D1C4	D1C5	D1C1	D1C2		D1C3	D1C4	D1C5	D1C1	D1C2		D1C3	D1C4	D1C5	D1C2	D1C4	D1C5	D1C1	D1C2			D1C3	D1C4	D1C5	D1C1	D1C2			D1C3	D1C4	D1C5	D1C1	D1C2		D1C3	D1C4	D1C5	D1C1	D1C2			D1C3	D1C4	D1C5	D1C2	D1C3	D1C4	D1C5	D1C2			D1C3	D1C4	D1C5	D1C1	D1C2		D1C3	D1C4	D1C5	D1C2	D1C4	D1C5	D1C2	D1C4	D1C5	D1C2	D1C4	D1C5	D1C1	D1C2	D1C3	D1C4	D1C5	D1C1	D1C2	D1C3	D1C4	D1C5	D1C1	D1C2		D1C3	D1C4	D1C5	D1C1	D1C2	D1C3	D1C4	D1C5	D1C2	D1C3	D1C4	D1C5	D1C2	D1C4	D1C5	D1C2	D1C3	D1C4	D1C5	D1C2	D1C4	D1C5	D1C2	D1C4	D1C5	D1C2		D1C3	D1C4	D1C5	D1C2		D1C3	D1C4	D1C5	D1C2		D1C3	D1C4	D1C5	D1C2	D1C4	D1C5	D1C2		D1C3	D1C4	D1C5	D1C2		D1C3	D1C4	D1C5	D1C2	D1C4	D1C5	D1C2		D1C3	D1C4	D1C5	D1C2	D1C4	D1C5	D1C2	D1C4	D1C5	D1C2		D1C3	D1C4	D1C5	D1C2		D1C3	D1C4	D1C5	D1C2	D1C4	D1C5	D1C2	D1C4	D1C5	D1C2		D1C3	D1C4	D1C5	D1C2		D1C3	D1C4	D1C5
Parameter	Mortality rate / Mortality rate from fishing (F)	Other		Other	Other	Mortality rate / Mortality rate from fishing (F)	Other		Other	Other	Other	Abundance	Other	Other	Other	Abundance	Other	Other	Other	Abundance	Other	Other	Other	Abundance	Other	Other	Other	Abundance	Other	Other	Mortality rate / Mortality rate from fishing (F)	Abundance	Other	Other	Other	Mortality rate / Mortality rate from fishing (F)	Abundance	Other	Other	Mortality rate / Mortality rate from fishing (F)	Abundance	Other	Other	Mortality rate / Mortality rate from fishing (F)	Abundance	Other	Other	Mortality rate / Mortality rate from fishing (F)	Other		Other	Other	Other	Mortality rate / Mortality rate from fishing (F)	Other		Other	Other	Other	Mortality rate / Mortality rate from fishing (F)	Other		Other	Other	Other	Mortality rate / Mortality rate from fishing (F)	Other		Other	Other	Other	Mortality rate / Mortality rate from fishing (F)	Other		Other	Other	Other	Abundance	Other	Other	Mortality rate / Mortality rate from fishing (F)	Other			Other	Other	Other	Mortality rate / Mortality rate from fishing (F)	Other			Other	Other	Other	Mortality rate / Mortality rate from fishing (F)	Other		Other	Other	Other	Mortality rate / Mortality rate from fishing (F)	Other			Other	Other	Other	Abundance	Other	Other	Other	Other			Other	Other	Other	Mortality rate / Mortality rate from fishing (F)	Other		Other	Other	Other	Abundance	Other	Other	Abundance	Other	Other	Abundance	Other	Other	Mortality rate / Mortality rate from fishing (F)	Abundance	Other	Other	Other	Mortality rate / Mortality rate from fishing (F)	Abundance	Other	Other	Other	Mortality rate / Mortality rate from fishing (F)	Other		Other	Other	Other	Mortality rate / Mortality rate from fishing (F)	Abundance	Other	Other	Other	Abundance	Other	Other	Other	Abundance	Other	Other	Abundance	Other	Other	Other	Abundance	Other	Other	Abundance	Other	Other	Other		Other	Other	Other	Other		Other	Other	Other	Other		Other	Other	Other	Abundance	Other	Other	Other		Other	Other	Other	Other		Other	Other	Other	Abundance	Other	Other	Other		Other	Other	Other	Abundance	Other	Other	Abundance	Other	Other	Other		Other	Other	Other	Other		Other	Other	Other	Abundance	Other	Other	Abundance	Other	Other	Other		Other	Other	Other	Other		Other	Other	Other
Parameter other		Abundance (number of individuals) – trend	Abundance (number of individuals) – wintering	Specific parameters related to distribution to be defined	Specific parameters related to habitat characteristics are still to be defined.		Abundance (number of individuals) – breeding	Abundance (number of individuals) – wintering	Breeding success / failure Brut	Specific parameters related to distribution to be defined	Specific parameters related to habitat characteristics are still to be defined.		Breeding success / failure Brut	Specific parameters related to distribution to be defined	Specific parameters related to habitat characteristics are still to be defined.		Breeding success / failure Brut	Specific parameters related to distribution to be defined	Specific parameters related to habitat characteristics are still to be defined.		Breeding success / failure Brut	Specific parameters related to distribution to be defined	Specific parameters related to habitat characteristics are still to be defined.		Breeding success / failure Brut	Specific parameters related to distribution to be defined	Specific parameters related to habitat characteristics are still to be defined.		Specific parameters related to distribution to be defined	Specific parameters related to habitat characteristics are still to be defined.			Annual collection rate	Specific parameters related to distribution to be defined	Specific parameters related to habitat characteristics are still to be defined.			Specific parameters related to distribution to be defined	Specific parameters related to habitat characteristics are still to be defined.			Specific parameters related to distribution to be defined	Specific parameters related to habitat characteristics are still to be defined.			Specific parameters related to distribution to be defined	Specific parameters related to habitat characteristics are still to be defined.		Abundance (number of individuals) – breeding	Abundance (number of individuals) – wintering	Breeding success / failure Brut	Specific parameters related to distribution to be defined	Specific parameters related to habitat characteristics are still to be defined.		Abundance (number of individuals) – breeding	Abundance (number of individuals) – trend	Breeding success / failure Brut	Specific parameters related to distribution to be defined	Specific parameters related to habitat characteristics are still to be defined.		Abundance (number of individuals) – breeding	Abundance (number of individuals) – wintering	Breeding success / failure Brut	Specific parameters related to distribution to be defined	Specific parameters related to habitat characteristics are still to be defined.		Abundance (number of individuals) – breeding	Abundance (number of individuals) – trend	Annual collection rate	Specific parameters related to distribution to be defined	Specific parameters related to habitat characteristics are still to be defined.		Abundance (number of individuals) – breeding	Abundance (number of individuals) – trend	Annual collection rate	Specific parameters related to distribution to be defined	Specific parameters related to habitat characteristics are still to be defined.		Specific parameters related to distribution to be defined	Specific parameters related to habitat characteristics are still to be defined.		Abundance (number of individuals) – breeding	Abundance (number of individuals) – trend	Abundance (number of individuals) – wintering	Annual collection rate	Specific parameters related to distribution to be defined	Specific parameters related to habitat characteristics are still to be defined.		Abundance (number of individuals) – breeding	Abundance (number of individuals) – trend	Abundance (number of individuals) – wintering	Breeding success / failure Brut	Specific parameters related to distribution to be defined	Specific parameters related to habitat characteristics are still to be defined.		Abundance (number of individuals) – breeding	Abundance (number of individuals) – trend	Annual collection rate	Specific parameters related to distribution to be defined	Specific parameters related to habitat characteristics are still to be defined.		Abundance (number of individuals) – breeding	Abundance (number of individuals) – trend	Abundance (number of individuals) – wintering	Breeding success / failure Brut	Specific parameters related to distribution to be defined	Specific parameters related to habitat characteristics are still to be defined.		Breeding success / failure Brut	Specific parameters related to distribution to be defined	Specific parameters related to habitat characteristics are still to be defined.	Abundance (number of individuals) – breeding	Abundance (number of individuals) – trend	Abundance (number of individuals) – wintering	Annual collection rate	Specific parameters related to distribution to be defined	Specific parameters related to habitat characteristics are still to be defined.		Abundance (number of individuals) – breeding	Abundance (number of individuals) – trend	Annual collection rate	Specific parameters related to distribution to be defined	Specific parameters related to habitat characteristics are still to be defined.		Specific parameters related to distribution to be defined	Specific parameters related to habitat characteristics are still to be defined.		Specific parameters related to distribution to be defined	Specific parameters related to habitat characteristics are still to be defined.		Specific parameters related to distribution to be defined	Specific parameters related to habitat characteristics are still to be defined.			Annual collection rate	Specific parameters related to distribution to be defined	Specific parameters related to habitat characteristics are still to be defined.			Annual collection rate	Specific parameters related to distribution to be defined	Specific parameters related to habitat characteristics are still to be defined.		Abundance (number of individuals) – breeding	Abundance (number of individuals) – trend	Annual collection rate	Specific parameters related to distribution to be defined	Specific parameters related to habitat characteristics are still to be defined.			Breeding success / failure Brut	Specific parameters related to distribution to be defined	Specific parameters related to habitat characteristics are still to be defined.		Breeding success / failure Brut	Specific parameters related to distribution to be defined	Specific parameters related to habitat characteristics are still to be defined.		Specific parameters related to distribution to be defined	Specific parameters related to habitat characteristics are still to be defined.		Breeding success / failure Brut	Specific parameters related to distribution to be defined	Specific parameters related to habitat characteristics are still to be defined.		Specific parameters related to distribution to be defined	Specific parameters related to habitat characteristics are still to be defined.		Specific parameters related to distribution to be defined	Specific parameters related to habitat characteristics are still to be defined.	Abundance (number of individuals) – breeding	Abundance (number of individuals) – wintering	Breeding success / failure Brut	Specific parameters related to distribution to be defined	Specific parameters related to habitat characteristics are still to be defined.	Abundance (number of individuals) – breeding	Abundance (number of individuals) – wintering	Breeding success / failure Brut	Specific parameters related to distribution to be defined	Specific parameters related to habitat characteristics are still to be defined.	Abundance (number of individuals) – trend	Abundance (number of individuals) – wintering	Ratio of reproduction to adult mortality	Specific parameters related to distribution to be defined	Specific parameters related to habitat characteristics are still to be defined.		Specific parameters related to distribution to be defined	Specific parameters related to habitat characteristics are still to be defined.	Abundance (number of individuals) – trend	Abundance (number of individuals) – wintering	Breeding success / failure Brut	Specific parameters related to distribution to be defined	Specific parameters related to habitat characteristics are still to be defined.	Abundance (number of individuals) – trend	Abundance (number of individuals) – wintering	Breeding success / failure Brut	Specific parameters related to distribution to be defined	Specific parameters related to habitat characteristics are still to be defined.		Specific parameters related to distribution to be defined	Specific parameters related to habitat characteristics are still to be defined.	Abundance (number of individuals) – breeding	Abundance (number of individuals) – wintering	Ratio of reproduction to adult mortality	Specific parameters related to distribution to be defined	Specific parameters related to habitat characteristics are still to be defined.		Specific parameters related to distribution to be defined	Specific parameters related to habitat characteristics are still to be defined.		Specific parameters related to distribution to be defined	Specific parameters related to habitat characteristics are still to be defined.	Abundance (number of individuals) – breeding	Abundance (number of individuals) – wintering	Ratio of reproduction to adult mortality	Specific parameters related to distribution to be defined	Specific parameters related to habitat characteristics are still to be defined.	Abundance (number of individuals) – trend	Abundance (number of individuals) – wintering	Breeding success / failure Brut	Specific parameters related to distribution to be defined	Specific parameters related to habitat characteristics are still to be defined.		Specific parameters related to distribution to be defined	Specific parameters related to habitat characteristics are still to be defined.		Specific parameters related to distribution to be defined	Specific parameters related to habitat characteristics are still to be defined.	Abundance (number of individuals) – trend	Abundance (number of individuals) – wintering	Breeding success / failure Brut	Specific parameters related to distribution to be defined	Specific parameters related to habitat characteristics are still to be defined.	Abundance (number of individuals) – trend	Abundance (number of individuals) – wintering	Breeding success / failure Brut	Specific parameters related to distribution to be defined	Specific parameters related to habitat characteristics are still to be defined.
Threshold value upper			0.7				0.7					0.7				0.7				0.7				0.7				0.7				0.8	3.0																0.7						0.8						0.7						0.8		3.0				0.8		3.0							0.7		0.7	3.0				0.7		0.7					0.7		3.0				0.7		0.7				0.7				0.7		0.7	3.0				0.7		3.0													0.7	3.0				0.7	3.0				0.7		3.0				0.7				0.7				0.7			0.7				0.7			0.7			0.7					0.7						0.7				0.7				0.7					0.7				0.7			0.7					0.7			0.7			0.7						0.7				0.7			0.7				0.7					0.7
Threshold value lower
Threshold qualitative		No significantly decreasing trend																															Number of years with a large-scale breeding failure, up to a maximum of 3 in 6 years.								no downward trend				No significantly decreasing trend.											no significantly decreasing trend												no significantly decreasing trend	Number of years with a large-scale breeding failure, up to a maximum of 3 in 6 years.					No significant decreasing trend	Number of years with a large-scale breeding failure, up to a maximum of 3 in 6 years.								No significantly decreasing trend		Number of years with a large-scale breeding loss in a maximum of 3 out of 6 years.					No significantly decreasing trend							No significantly decreasing trend	Number of years with a large-scale breeding loss in a maximum of 3 out of 6 years.					No significantly decreasing trend										No significantly decreasing trend		Number of years with a large-scale breeding loss in a maximum of 3 out of 6 years.					no significantly decreasing trend	Number of years with a large-scale breeding loss in a maximum of 3 out of 6 years.														Number of years with a large-scale breeding loss in a maximum of 3 out of 6 years.					Number of years with a large-scale breeding loss in a maximum of 3 out of 6 years.					No significantly decreasing trend	Number of years with a large-scale breeding loss in a maximum of 3 out of 6 years.																																			No significantly decreasing trend.		Reproduction is higher than the mortality of adults.						No significantly decreasing trend.					No significantly decreasing trend.										Reproduction is higher than the mortality of adults.											Reproduction is higher than the mortality of adults.			No significantly decreasing trend.											No significantly decreasing trend.					No significantly decreasing trend.
Threshold value source		Other (specify)	OSPAR Convention				OSPAR Convention					OSPAR Convention				OSPAR Convention				OSPAR Convention				OSPAR Convention				OSPAR Convention				OSPAR Convention	OSPAR Convention								Other (specify)				Other (specify)				OSPAR Convention						OSPAR Convention	Other (specify)					OSPAR Convention						OSPAR Convention	Other (specify)	OSPAR Convention				OSPAR Convention	Other (specify)	OSPAR Convention							OSPAR Convention	Other (specify)	OSPAR Convention	OSPAR Convention				OSPAR Convention	Other (specify)	OSPAR Convention					OSPAR Convention	Other (specify)	OSPAR Convention				OSPAR Convention	Other (specify)	OSPAR Convention				OSPAR Convention				OSPAR Convention	Other (specify)	OSPAR Convention					OSPAR Convention	Other (specify)	OSPAR Convention													OSPAR Convention	OSPAR Convention				OSPAR Convention	OSPAR Convention				OSPAR Convention	Other (specify)					OSPAR Convention				OSPAR Convention				OSPAR Convention			OSPAR Convention				OSPAR Convention			OSPAR Convention			OSPAR Convention					OSPAR Convention					Other (specify)	OSPAR Convention	Trilateral Wadden Sea Cooperation			OSPAR Convention			Other (specify)	OSPAR Convention				Other (specify)	OSPAR Convention				OSPAR Convention			OSPAR Convention		Trilateral Wadden Sea Cooperation			OSPAR Convention			OSPAR Convention			OSPAR Convention		Trilateral Wadden Sea Cooperation			Other (specify)	OSPAR Convention				OSPAR Convention			OSPAR Convention			Other (specify)	OSPAR Convention				Other (specify)	OSPAR Convention
Threshold value source other		National supplement for abundance assessment resting birds offshore.																																							National supplement for abundance assessment resting birds offshore.				National supplement for abundance assessment resting birds offshore.											National supplement for abundance assessment resting birds offshore.												National supplement for abundance assessment resting birds offshore.						National supplement for abundance assessment resting birds offshore.									National supplement for abundance assessment resting birds offshore.							National supplement for abundance assessment resting birds offshore.							National supplement for abundance assessment resting birds offshore.						National supplement for abundance assessment resting birds offshore.										National supplement for abundance assessment resting birds offshore.							National supplement for abundance assessment resting birds offshore.																									National supplement for abundance assessment resting birds offshore.																																				National supplement for abundance assessment, breeding birds (TWSC data)								National supplement for abundance assessment, breeding birds (TWSC data)					National supplement for abundance assessment, breeding birds (TWSC data)																								National supplement for abundance assessment, breeding birds (TWSC data)											National supplement for abundance assessment, breeding birds (TWSC data)					National supplement for abundance assessment, breeding birds (TWSC data)
Value achieved upper			8.971				14.1968	0.4847				2.0209				1.6036				0.7478				0.8996				0.8155				13.8279																	0.0833	1.7538					118.8566						1.1512	1.4015					1.4296						1.1973									0.4124		0.5573					0.3688		1.0137					1.5239		1.0				8.2133		0.7122				152.4791				0.5067		0.9591	6.0				0.829															0.5339	6.0				0.4452	4.0				0.7446		5.0				0.8485				0.66				2.0555			0.8234				0.8637			0.0625			0.1047	0.2292				1.4666	1.1046					0.5408				1.1514				2.2148					1.0416				1.4201			20.3664	8.6196				1.3373			0.7603			0.4458	0.7773					1.1814				0.4343			0.9697				0.6683					0.7519
Value achieved lower
Value unit		Other					Other					Other				Other				Other				Other				Other				Other									Other				Other				Other						Other						Other						Other						Other									Other							Other							Other						Other						Other				Other							Other															Other					Other					Other						Other				Other				Other			Other				Other			Other			Other					Other					Other					Other			Other					Other					Other			Other					Other			Other			Other					Other					Other			Other			Other					Other
Value unit other		Abundance of waterbirds in the wintering season, offshore area	Winter age index (OSPAR)				Convention for the abundance of breeding birds, OSPAR	Winter age index (OSPAR)				Winter age index (OSPAR)				Winter age index (OSPAR)				Winter age index (OSPAR)				Winter age index (OSPAR)				Winter age index (OSPAR)				Convention for the abundance of breeding birds, OSPAR									Abundance of waterbirds in the wintering season, offshore area				Abundance of waterbirds in the wintering season, offshore area				Convention for the abundance of breeding birds, OSPAR	Winter age index (OSPAR)					Convention for the abundance of breeding birds, OSPAR	Abundance of waterbirds in the wintering season, offshore area					Convention for the abundance of breeding birds, OSPAR	Winter age index (OSPAR)					Convention for the abundance of breeding birds, OSPAR	Abundance of waterbirds in the wintering season, offshore area					Convention for the abundance of breeding birds, OSPAR	Abundance of waterbirds in the wintering season, offshore area								Convention for the abundance of breeding birds, OSPAR	Abundance of waterbirds in the wintering season, offshore area	Winter age index (OSPAR)					Convention for the abundance of breeding birds, OSPAR	Abundance of waterbirds in the wintering season, offshore area	Winter age index (OSPAR)					Convention for the abundance of breeding birds, OSPAR	Abundance of waterbirds in the wintering season, offshore area					Convention for the abundance of breeding birds, OSPAR	Abundance of waterbirds in the wintering season, offshore area	Winter age index (OSPAR)				Convention for the abundance of breeding birds, OSPAR				Convention for the abundance of breeding birds, OSPAR	Abundance of waterbirds in the wintering season, offshore area	Winter age index (OSPAR)					Convention for the abundance of breeding birds, OSPAR	Abundance of waterbirds in the wintering season, offshore area														Convention for the abundance of breeding birds, OSPAR					Convention for the abundance of breeding birds, OSPAR					Convention for the abundance of breeding birds, OSPAR	Abundance of waterbirds in the wintering season, offshore area					Convention for the abundance of breeding birds, OSPAR				Winter age index (OSPAR)				Winter age index (OSPAR)			Winter age index (OSPAR)				Winter age index (OSPAR)			Winter age index (OSPAR)			Convention for the abundance of breeding birds, OSPAR	Winter age index (OSPAR)				Convention for the abundance of breeding birds, OSPAR	Winter age index (OSPAR)				Abundance of Waterbird in the bregrading sason	Winter age index (OSPAR)				Winter age index (OSPAR)			Abundance of Waterbird in the bregrading sason	Winter age index (OSPAR)				Abundance of Waterbird in the bregrading sason	Winter age index (OSPAR)				Winter age index (OSPAR)			Convention for the abundance of breeding birds, OSPAR	Winter age index (OSPAR)				Winter age index (OSPAR)			Winter age index (OSPAR)			Convention for the abundance of breeding birds, OSPAR	Winter age index (OSPAR)				Abundance of Waterbird in the bregrading sason	Winter age index (OSPAR)				Winter age index (OSPAR)			Winter age index (OSPAR)			Abundance of Waterbird in the bregrading sason	Winter age index (OSPAR)				Abundance of Waterbird in the bregrading sason	Winter age index (OSPAR)
Proportion threshold value
Proportion value achieved
Proportion threshold value unit
Trend	Unknown	Stable	Not relevant	Unknown	Unknown	Unknown	Not relevant		Unknown	Unknown	Unknown	Not relevant	Unknown	Unknown	Unknown	Not relevant	Unknown	Unknown	Unknown	Not relevant	Unknown	Unknown	Unknown	Not relevant	Unknown	Unknown	Unknown	Not relevant	Unknown	Unknown	Unknown	Not relevant	Not relevant	Unknown	Unknown	Unknown	Unknown	Unknown	Unknown	Unknown	Stable	Unknown	Unknown	Unknown	Stable	Unknown	Unknown	Unknown	Not relevant		Unknown	Unknown	Unknown	Unknown	Not relevant	Stable	Unknown	Unknown	Unknown	Unknown	Not relevant		Unknown	Unknown	Unknown	Unknown	Not relevant	Improving	Not relevant	Unknown	Unknown	Unknown	Not relevant	Deteriorating	Not relevant	Unknown	Unknown	Unknown	Unknown	Unknown	Unknown	Not relevant	Deteriorating	Not relevant	Not relevant	Unknown	Unknown	Unknown	Not relevant	Deteriorating	Not relevant	Unknown	Unknown	Unknown	Unknown	Not relevant	Stable	Not relevant	Unknown	Unknown	Unknown	Not relevant	Deteriorating	Not relevant	Unknown	Unknown	Unknown	Not relevant	Unknown	Unknown	Unknown	Not relevant	Improving	Not relevant	Not relevant	Unknown	Unknown	Unknown	Not relevant	Deteriorating	Not relevant	Unknown	Unknown	Unknown	Unknown	Unknown	Unknown	Unknown	Unknown	Unknown	Unknown	Unknown	Unknown	Not relevant	Not relevant	Unknown	Unknown	Unknown	Not relevant	Not relevant	Unknown	Unknown	Unknown	Not relevant	Deteriorating	Not relevant	Unknown	Unknown	Unknown	Not relevant	Unknown	Unknown	Unknown	Not relevant	Unknown	Unknown	Unknown	Not relevant	Unknown	Unknown	Not relevant	Unknown	Unknown	Unknown	Not relevant	Unknown	Unknown	Not relevant	Unknown	Unknown	Not relevant		Unknown	Unknown	Unknown	Not relevant		Unknown	Unknown	Unknown	Deteriorating	Not relevant	Not relevant	Unknown	Unknown	Not relevant	Unknown	Unknown	Deteriorating	Not relevant	Unknown	Unknown	Unknown	Deteriorating	Not relevant	Unknown	Unknown	Unknown	Not relevant	Unknown	Unknown	Not relevant		Not relevant	Unknown	Unknown	Not relevant	Unknown	Unknown	Not relevant	Unknown	Unknown	Not relevant		Not relevant	Unknown	Unknown	Improving	Not relevant	Unknown	Unknown	Unknown	Not relevant	Unknown	Unknown	Not relevant	Unknown	Unknown	Deteriorating	Not relevant	Unknown	Unknown	Unknown	Deteriorating	Not relevant	Unknown	Unknown	Unknown
Parameter achieved	Unknown	Yes		Not assessed	Not assessed	Unknown	Yes	No	Not assessed	Not assessed	Not assessed	Yes	Not assessed	Not assessed	Not assessed	Yes	Not assessed	Not assessed	Not assessed	Yes	Not assessed	Not assessed	Not assessed	Yes	Not assessed	Not assessed	Not assessed	Yes	Not assessed	Not assessed	Unknown	Yes	Yes	Not assessed	Not assessed	Unknown	Not assessed	Not assessed	Not assessed	Unknown	Yes	Not assessed	Not assessed	Unknown	Yes	Not assessed	Not assessed	Unknown	No	Yes	Not assessed	Not assessed	Not assessed	Unknown	Yes		Not assessed	Not assessed	Not assessed	Unknown	Yes		Not assessed	Not assessed	Not assessed	Unknown	Yes		Yes	Not assessed	Not assessed	Unknown	Yes	No	Yes	Not assessed	Not assessed	Not assessed	Not assessed	Not assessed	Unknown	No			Not assessed	Not assessed	Not assessed	Unknown	No		Not assessed	Not assessed	Not assessed	Not assessed	Unknown	Not assessed		Not assessed	Not assessed	Not assessed	Unknown	Not assessed	No	Not assessed	Not assessed	Not assessed	Not assessed	Yes	Not assessed	Not assessed	Not assessed	No	Yes		No	Not assessed	Not assessed	Unknown	Yes	No	Yes	Not assessed	Not assessed	Not assessed	Not assessed	Not assessed	Not assessed	Not assessed	Not assessed	Not assessed	Not assessed	Not assessed	Unknown	No	No	Not assessed	Not assessed	Unknown	No	No	Not assessed	Not assessed	Unknown	Not assessed	No	No	Not assessed	Not assessed	Unknown	Not assessed	Not assessed	Not assessed	Not assessed	No	Not assessed	Not assessed	Not assessed	Yes	Not assessed	Not assessed	Yes	Not assessed	Not assessed	Not assessed	Yes	Not assessed	Not assessed	No	Not assessed	Not assessed	No		Not assessed	Not assessed	Not assessed	Yes		Not assessed	Not assessed	Not assessed	No		No	Not assessed	Not assessed	Yes	Not assessed	Not assessed	No	Yes	Not assessed	Not assessed	Not assessed	No	Yes	Not assessed	Not assessed	Not assessed	Yes	Not assessed	Not assessed	Yes		Yes	Not assessed	Not assessed	Yes	Not assessed	Not assessed	Yes	Not assessed	Not assessed	No	Yes	No	Not assessed	Not assessed	Yes		Not assessed	Not assessed	Not assessed	No	Not assessed	Not assessed	Yes	Not assessed	Not assessed	No		Not assessed	Not assessed	Not assessed	No	Yes	Not assessed	Not assessed	Not assessed
Description parameter			The indicator is used for the first time under the 2018 MSFD report, so no trend is reported.				The indicator is used for the first time under the 2018 MSFD report, so no trend is reported.					The indicator is used for the first time under the 2018 MSFD report, so no trend is reported.				The indicator is used for the first time under the 2018 MSFD report, so no trend is reported.				The indicator is used for the first time under the 2018 MSFD report, so no trend is reported.				The indicator is used for the first time under the 2018 MSFD report, so no trend is reported.				The indicator is used for the first time under the 2018 MSFD report, so no trend is reported.				The indicator is used for the first time under the 2018 MSFD report, so no trend is reported.	The indicator is used for the first time under the 2018 MSFD report, so no trend is reported.																The indicator is used for the first time under the 2018 MSFD report, so no trend is reported.						The indicator is used for the first time under the 2018 MSFD report, so no trend is reported.						The indicator is used for the first time under the 2018 MSFD report, so no trend is reported.						The indicator is used for the first time under the 2018 MSFD report, so no trend is reported.		The indicator is used for the first time under the 2018 MSFD report, so no trend is reported.				The indicator is used for the first time under the 2018 MSFD report, so no trend is reported.		The indicator is used for the first time under the 2018 MSFD report, so no trend is reported.							The indicator is used for the first time under the 2018 MSFD report, so no trend is reported.		The indicator is used for the first time under the 2018 MSFD report, so no trend is reported.	The indicator is used for the first time under the 2018 MSFD report, so no trend is reported.				The indicator is used for the first time under the 2018 MSFD report, so no trend is reported.		The indicator is used for the first time under the 2018 MSFD report, so no trend is reported.					The indicator is used for the first time under the 2018 MSFD report, so no trend is reported.		The indicator is used for the first time under the 2018 MSFD report, so no trend is reported.				The indicator is used for the first time under the 2018 MSFD report, so no trend is reported.		The indicator is used for the first time under the 2018 MSFD report, so no trend is reported.				The indicator is used for the first time under the 2018 MSFD report, so no trend is reported.				The indicator is used for the first time under the 2018 MSFD report, so no trend is reported.		The indicator is used for the first time under the 2018 MSFD report, so no trend is reported.	The indicator is used for the first time under the 2018 MSFD report, so no trend is reported.				The indicator is used for the first time under the 2018 MSFD report, so no trend is reported.		The indicator is used for the first time under the 2018 MSFD report, so no trend is reported.													The indicator is used for the first time under the 2018 MSFD report, so no trend is reported.	The indicator is used for the first time under the 2018 MSFD report, so no trend is reported.				The indicator is used for the first time under the 2018 MSFD report, so no trend is reported.	The indicator is used for the first time under the 2018 MSFD report, so no trend is reported.				The indicator is used for the first time under the 2018 MSFD report, so no trend is reported.		The indicator is used for the first time under the 2018 MSFD report, so no trend is reported.				The indicator is used for the first time under the 2018 MSFD report, so no trend is reported.				The indicator is used for the first time under the 2018 MSFD report, so no trend is reported.				The indicator is used for the first time under the 2018 MSFD report, so no trend is reported.			The indicator is used for the first time under the 2018 MSFD report, so no trend is reported.				The indicator is used for the first time under the 2018 MSFD report, so no trend is reported.			The indicator is used for the first time under the 2018 MSFD report, so no trend is reported.			The indicator is used for the first time under the 2018 MSFD report, so no trend is reported.					The indicator is used for the first time under the 2018 MSFD report, so no trend is reported.						The indicator is used for the first time under the 2018 MSFD report, so no trend is reported.	The indicator is used for the first time under the 2018 MSFD report, so no trend is reported. Data from TWSC monitoring were used for the evaluation. http://www.waddensea-secretariat.org/sites/default/files/downloads/manual_breedingsuccess_version2011.pdf			The indicator is used for the first time under the 2018 MSFD report, so no trend is reported.				The indicator is used for the first time under the 2018 MSFD report, so no trend is reported.					The indicator is used for the first time under the 2018 MSFD report, so no trend is reported.				The indicator is used for the first time under the 2018 MSFD report, so no trend is reported.			The indicator is used for the first time under the 2018 MSFD report, so no trend is reported.		The indicator is used for the first time under the 2018 MSFD report, so no trend is reported. Data from TWSC monitoring were used for the evaluation. http://www.waddensea-secretariat.org/sites/default/files/downloads/manual_breedingsuccess_version2011.pdf			The indicator is used for the first time under the 2018 MSFD report, so no trend is reported.			The indicator is used for the first time under the 2018 MSFD report, so no trend is reported.			The indicator is used for the first time under the 2018 MSFD report, so no trend is reported.		The indicator is used for the first time under the 2018 MSFD report, so no trend is reported. Data from TWSC monitoring were used for the evaluation. http://www.waddensea-secretariat.org/sites/default/files/downloads/manual_breedingsuccess_version2011.pdf				The indicator is used for the first time under the 2018 MSFD report, so no trend is reported.				The indicator is used for the first time under the 2018 MSFD report, so no trend is reported.			The indicator is used for the first time under the 2018 MSFD report, so no trend is reported.				The indicator is used for the first time under the 2018 MSFD report, so no trend is reported.					The indicator is used for the first time under the 2018 MSFD report, so no trend is reported.
Related indicator		Trend der Artpopulation (Daten aus nationalem Monitoring und/oder TWSC)	Marine Bird Abundance				Marine Bird Abundance					Marine Bird Abundance				Marine Bird Abundance				Marine Bird Abundance				Marine Bird Abundance				Marine Bird Abundance				Marine Bird Abundance	Marine Bird Breeding Success or Failure								Trend der Artpopulation (Daten aus nationalem Monitoring und/oder TWSC)				Trend der Artpopulation (Daten aus nationalem Monitoring und/oder TWSC)				Marine Bird Abundance						Marine Bird Abundance	Trend der Artpopulation (Daten aus nationalem Monitoring und/oder TWSC)					Marine Bird Abundance						Marine Bird Abundance	Trend der Artpopulation (Daten aus nationalem Monitoring und/oder TWSC)	Marine Bird Breeding Success or Failure				Marine Bird Abundance	Trend der Artpopulation (Daten aus nationalem Monitoring und/oder TWSC)	Marine Bird Breeding Success or Failure							Marine Bird Abundance	Trend der Artpopulation (Daten aus nationalem Monitoring und/oder TWSC)	Marine Bird Abundance	Marine Bird Breeding Success or Failure				Marine Bird Abundance	Trend der Artpopulation (Daten aus nationalem Monitoring und/oder TWSC)	Marine Bird Abundance					Marine Bird Abundance	Trend der Artpopulation (Daten aus nationalem Monitoring und/oder TWSC)	Marine Bird Breeding Success or Failure				Marine Bird Abundance	Trend der Artpopulation (Daten aus nationalem Monitoring und/oder TWSC)	Marine Bird Abundance				Marine Bird Abundance				Marine Bird Abundance	Trend der Artpopulation (Daten aus nationalem Monitoring und/oder TWSC)	Marine Bird Abundance	Marine Bird Breeding Success or Failure				Marine Bird Abundance	Trend der Artpopulation (Daten aus nationalem Monitoring und/oder TWSC)	Marine Bird Breeding Success or Failure													Marine Bird Abundance	Marine Bird Breeding Success or Failure				Marine Bird Abundance	Marine Bird Breeding Success or Failure				Marine Bird Abundance	Trend der Artpopulation (Daten aus nationalem Monitoring und/oder TWSC)	Marine Bird Breeding Success or Failure				Marine Bird Abundance				Marine Bird Abundance				Marine Bird Abundance			Marine Bird Abundance				Marine Bird Abundance			Marine Bird Abundance			Marine Bird Abundance					Marine Bird Abundance					Trend der Artpopulation (Daten aus nationalem Monitoring und/oder TWSC)	Marine Bird Abundance				Marine Bird Abundance			Trend der Artpopulation (Daten aus nationalem Monitoring und/oder TWSC)	Marine Bird Abundance				Trend der Artpopulation (Daten aus nationalem Monitoring und/oder TWSC)	Marine Bird Abundance				Marine Bird Abundance			Marine Bird Abundance					Marine Bird Abundance			Marine Bird Abundance			Marine Bird Abundance					Trend der Artpopulation (Daten aus nationalem Monitoring und/oder TWSC)	Marine Bird Abundance				Marine Bird Abundance			Marine Bird Abundance			Trend der Artpopulation (Daten aus nationalem Monitoring und/oder TWSC)	Marine Bird Abundance				Trend der Artpopulation (Daten aus nationalem Monitoring und/oder TWSC)	Marine Bird Abundance
Criteria status	Not assessed	Good		Not assessed	Not assessed	Not assessed	Not good		Not assessed	Not assessed	Not assessed	Good	Not assessed	Not assessed	Not assessed	Good	Not assessed	Not assessed	Not assessed	Good	Not assessed	Not assessed	Not assessed	Good	Not assessed	Not assessed	Not assessed	Good	Not assessed	Not assessed	Not assessed	Good	Good	Not assessed	Not assessed	Not assessed	Not assessed	Not assessed	Not assessed	Not assessed	Good	Not assessed	Not assessed	Not assessed	Good	Not assessed	Not assessed	Not assessed	Not good		Not assessed	Not assessed	Not assessed	Not assessed	Good		Not assessed	Not assessed	Not assessed	Not assessed	Good		Not assessed	Not assessed	Not assessed	Not assessed	Good		Good	Not assessed	Not assessed	Not assessed	Not good		Good	Not assessed	Not assessed	Not assessed	Not assessed	Not assessed	Not assessed	Not good			Good	Not assessed	Not assessed	Not assessed	Not good			Not assessed	Not assessed	Not assessed	Not assessed	Good		Good	Not assessed	Not assessed	Not assessed	Not good			Not assessed	Not assessed	Not assessed	Good	Not assessed	Not assessed	Not assessed	Not good			Not good	Not assessed	Not assessed	Not assessed	Not good		Good	Not assessed	Not assessed	Not assessed	Not assessed	Not assessed	Not assessed	Not assessed	Not assessed	Not assessed	Not assessed	Not assessed	Not assessed	Not good	Not good	Not assessed	Not assessed	Not assessed	Not good	Not good	Not assessed	Not assessed	Not assessed	Not good		Not good	Not assessed	Not assessed	Not assessed	Good	Not assessed	Not assessed	Not assessed	Not good	Not assessed	Not assessed	Not assessed	Good	Not assessed	Not assessed	Good	Not assessed	Not assessed	Not assessed	Good	Not assessed	Not assessed	Not good	Not assessed	Not assessed	Not good		Not assessed	Not assessed	Not assessed	Good		Not assessed	Not assessed	Not assessed	Not good		Not good	Not assessed	Not assessed	Good	Not assessed	Not assessed	Not good		Not assessed	Not assessed	Not assessed	Not good		Not assessed	Not assessed	Not assessed	Good	Not assessed	Not assessed	Good		Good	Not assessed	Not assessed	Good	Not assessed	Not assessed	Good	Not assessed	Not assessed	Not good		Not good	Not assessed	Not assessed	Good		Not assessed	Not assessed	Not assessed	Not good	Not assessed	Not assessed	Good	Not assessed	Not assessed	Not good		Not assessed	Not assessed	Not assessed	Not good		Not assessed	Not assessed	Not assessed
Description criteria	Insufficient data are available for the assessment of criterion D1C1.			There are as yet no operational indicators to assess the spread of species (criterion D1C4) and the condition of habitats (criterion D1C5).	There are as yet no operational indicators to assess the spread of species (criterion D1C4) and the condition of habitats (criterion D1C5).	Insufficient data are available for the assessment of criterion D1C1.			Data base not sufficient for the assessment of criterion D1C3 for this species.	There are as yet no operational indicators to assess the spread of species (criterion D1C4) and the condition of habitats (criterion D1C5).	There are as yet no operational indicators to assess the spread of species (criterion D1C4) and the condition of habitats (criterion D1C5).		Data base not sufficient for the assessment of criterion D1C3 for this species.	There are as yet no operational indicators to assess the spread of species (criterion D1C4) and the condition of habitats (criterion D1C5).	There are as yet no operational indicators to assess the spread of species (criterion D1C4) and the condition of habitats (criterion D1C5).		Data base not sufficient for the assessment of criterion D1C3 for this species.	There are as yet no operational indicators to assess the spread of species (criterion D1C4) and the condition of habitats (criterion D1C5).	There are as yet no operational indicators to assess the spread of species (criterion D1C4) and the condition of habitats (criterion D1C5).		Data base not sufficient for the assessment of criterion D1C3 for this species.	There are as yet no operational indicators to assess the spread of species (criterion D1C4) and the condition of habitats (criterion D1C5).	There are as yet no operational indicators to assess the spread of species (criterion D1C4) and the condition of habitats (criterion D1C5).		Data base not sufficient for the assessment of criterion D1C3 for this species.	There are as yet no operational indicators to assess the spread of species (criterion D1C4) and the condition of habitats (criterion D1C5).	There are as yet no operational indicators to assess the spread of species (criterion D1C4) and the condition of habitats (criterion D1C5).		There are as yet no operational indicators to assess the spread of species (criterion D1C4) and the condition of habitats (criterion D1C5).	There are as yet no operational indicators to assess the spread of species (criterion D1C4) and the condition of habitats (criterion D1C5).	Insufficient data are available for the assessment of criterion D1C1.			There are as yet no operational indicators to assess the spread of species (criterion D1C4) and the condition of habitats (criterion D1C5).	There are as yet no operational indicators to assess the spread of species (criterion D1C4) and the condition of habitats (criterion D1C5).	Insufficient data are available for the assessment of criterion D1C1.	Insufficient data are available for the assessment of criterion D1C2.	There are as yet no operational indicators to assess the spread of species (criterion D1C4) and the condition of habitats (criterion D1C5).	There are as yet no operational indicators to assess the spread of species (criterion D1C4) and the condition of habitats (criterion D1C5).	Insufficient data are available for the assessment of criterion D1C1.		There are as yet no operational indicators to assess the spread of species (criterion D1C4) and the condition of habitats (criterion D1C5).	There are as yet no operational indicators to assess the spread of species (criterion D1C4) and the condition of habitats (criterion D1C5).	Insufficient data are available for the assessment of criterion D1C1.		There are as yet no operational indicators to assess the spread of species (criterion D1C4) and the condition of habitats (criterion D1C5).	There are as yet no operational indicators to assess the spread of species (criterion D1C4) and the condition of habitats (criterion D1C5).	Insufficient data are available for the assessment of criterion D1C1.			Data base not sufficient for the assessment of criterion D1C3 for this species.	There are as yet no operational indicators to assess the spread of species (criterion D1C4) and the condition of habitats (criterion D1C5).	There are as yet no operational indicators to assess the spread of species (criterion D1C4) and the condition of habitats (criterion D1C5).	Insufficient data are available for the assessment of criterion D1C1.			Data base not sufficient for the assessment of criterion D1C3 for this species.	There are as yet no operational indicators to assess the spread of species (criterion D1C4) and the condition of habitats (criterion D1C5).	There are as yet no operational indicators to assess the spread of species (criterion D1C4) and the condition of habitats (criterion D1C5).	Insufficient data are available for the assessment of criterion D1C1.			Data base not sufficient for the assessment of criterion D1C3 for this species.	There are as yet no operational indicators to assess the spread of species (criterion D1C4) and the condition of habitats (criterion D1C5).	There are as yet no operational indicators to assess the spread of species (criterion D1C4) and the condition of habitats (criterion D1C5).	Insufficient data are available for the assessment of criterion D1C1.				There are as yet no operational indicators to assess the spread of species (criterion D1C4) and the condition of habitats (criterion D1C5).	There are as yet no operational indicators to assess the spread of species (criterion D1C4) and the condition of habitats (criterion D1C5).	Insufficient data are available for the assessment of criterion D1C1.				There are as yet no operational indicators to assess the spread of species (criterion D1C4) and the condition of habitats (criterion D1C5).	There are as yet no operational indicators to assess the spread of species (criterion D1C4) and the condition of habitats (criterion D1C5).	Data base not sufficient for the assessment of criterion D1C2 for this species.	There are as yet no operational indicators to assess the spread of species (criterion D1C4) and the condition of habitats (criterion D1C5).	There are as yet no operational indicators to assess the spread of species (criterion D1C4) and the condition of habitats (criterion D1C5).	Insufficient data are available for the assessment of criterion D1C1.					There are as yet no operational indicators to assess the spread of species (criterion D1C4) and the condition of habitats (criterion D1C5).	There are as yet no operational indicators to assess the spread of species (criterion D1C4) and the condition of habitats (criterion D1C5).	Insufficient data are available for the assessment of criterion D1C1.				Data base not sufficient for the assessment of criterion D1C3 for this species.	There are as yet no operational indicators to assess the spread of species (criterion D1C4) and the condition of habitats (criterion D1C5).	There are as yet no operational indicators to assess the spread of species (criterion D1C4) and the condition of habitats (criterion D1C5).	Insufficient data are available for the assessment of criterion D1C1.				There are as yet no operational indicators to assess the spread of species (criterion D1C4) and the condition of habitats (criterion D1C5).	There are as yet no operational indicators to assess the spread of species (criterion D1C4) and the condition of habitats (criterion D1C5).	Insufficient data are available for the assessment of criterion D1C1.				Data base not sufficient for the assessment of criterion D1C3 for this species.	There are as yet no operational indicators to assess the spread of species (criterion D1C4) and the condition of habitats (criterion D1C5).	There are as yet no operational indicators to assess the spread of species (criterion D1C4) and the condition of habitats (criterion D1C5).		Data base not sufficient for the assessment of criterion D1C3 for this species.	There are as yet no operational indicators to assess the spread of species (criterion D1C4) and the condition of habitats (criterion D1C5).	There are as yet no operational indicators to assess the spread of species (criterion D1C4) and the condition of habitats (criterion D1C5).					There are as yet no operational indicators to assess the spread of species (criterion D1C4) and the condition of habitats (criterion D1C5).	There are as yet no operational indicators to assess the spread of species (criterion D1C4) and the condition of habitats (criterion D1C5).	Insufficient data are available for the assessment of criterion D1C1.				There are as yet no operational indicators to assess the spread of species (criterion D1C4) and the condition of habitats (criterion D1C5).	There are as yet no operational indicators to assess the spread of species (criterion D1C4) and the condition of habitats (criterion D1C5).	Data base not sufficient for the assessment of criterion D1C2 for this species.	There are as yet no operational indicators to assess the spread of species (criterion D1C4) and the condition of habitats (criterion D1C5).	There are as yet no operational indicators to assess the spread of species (criterion D1C4) and the condition of habitats (criterion D1C5).	Data base not sufficient for the assessment of criterion D1C2 for this species.	There are as yet no operational indicators to assess the spread of species (criterion D1C4) and the condition of habitats (criterion D1C5).	There are as yet no operational indicators to assess the spread of species (criterion D1C4) and the condition of habitats (criterion D1C5).	Data base not sufficient for the assessment of criterion D1C2 for this species.	There are as yet no operational indicators to assess the spread of species (criterion D1C4) and the condition of habitats (criterion D1C5).	There are as yet no operational indicators to assess the spread of species (criterion D1C4) and the condition of habitats (criterion D1C5).	Insufficient data are available for the assessment of criterion D1C1.			There are as yet no operational indicators to assess the spread of species (criterion D1C4) and the condition of habitats (criterion D1C5).	There are as yet no operational indicators to assess the spread of species (criterion D1C4) and the condition of habitats (criterion D1C5).	Insufficient data are available for the assessment of criterion D1C1.			There are as yet no operational indicators to assess the spread of species (criterion D1C4) and the condition of habitats (criterion D1C5).	There are as yet no operational indicators to assess the spread of species (criterion D1C4) and the condition of habitats (criterion D1C5).	Insufficient data are available for the assessment of criterion D1C1.				There are as yet no operational indicators to assess the spread of species (criterion D1C4) and the condition of habitats (criterion D1C5).	There are as yet no operational indicators to assess the spread of species (criterion D1C4) and the condition of habitats (criterion D1C5).	Insufficient data are available for the assessment of criterion D1C1.		Data base not sufficient for the assessment of criterion D1C3 for this species.	There are as yet no operational indicators to assess the spread of species (criterion D1C4) and the condition of habitats (criterion D1C5).	There are as yet no operational indicators to assess the spread of species (criterion D1C4) and the condition of habitats (criterion D1C5).		Data base not sufficient for the assessment of criterion D1C3 for this species.	There are as yet no operational indicators to assess the spread of species (criterion D1C4) and the condition of habitats (criterion D1C5).	There are as yet no operational indicators to assess the spread of species (criterion D1C4) and the condition of habitats (criterion D1C5).		There are as yet no operational indicators to assess the spread of species (criterion D1C4) and the condition of habitats (criterion D1C5).	There are as yet no operational indicators to assess the spread of species (criterion D1C4) and the condition of habitats (criterion D1C5).		Data base not sufficient for the assessment of criterion D1C3 for this species.	There are as yet no operational indicators to assess the spread of species (criterion D1C4) and the condition of habitats (criterion D1C5).	There are as yet no operational indicators to assess the spread of species (criterion D1C4) and the condition of habitats (criterion D1C5).		There are as yet no operational indicators to assess the spread of species (criterion D1C4) and the condition of habitats (criterion D1C5).	There are as yet no operational indicators to assess the spread of species (criterion D1C4) and the condition of habitats (criterion D1C5).		There are as yet no operational indicators to assess the spread of species (criterion D1C4) and the condition of habitats (criterion D1C5).	There are as yet no operational indicators to assess the spread of species (criterion D1C4) and the condition of habitats (criterion D1C5).			Data base not sufficient for the assessment of criterion D1C3 for this species.	There are as yet no operational indicators to assess the spread of species (criterion D1C4) and the condition of habitats (criterion D1C5).	There are as yet no operational indicators to assess the spread of species (criterion D1C4) and the condition of habitats (criterion D1C5).			Data base not sufficient for the assessment of criterion D1C3 for this species.	There are as yet no operational indicators to assess the spread of species (criterion D1C4) and the condition of habitats (criterion D1C5).	There are as yet no operational indicators to assess the spread of species (criterion D1C4) and the condition of habitats (criterion D1C5).				There are as yet no operational indicators to assess the spread of species (criterion D1C4) and the condition of habitats (criterion D1C5).	There are as yet no operational indicators to assess the spread of species (criterion D1C4) and the condition of habitats (criterion D1C5).		There are as yet no operational indicators to assess the spread of species (criterion D1C4) and the condition of habitats (criterion D1C5).	There are as yet no operational indicators to assess the spread of species (criterion D1C4) and the condition of habitats (criterion D1C5).			Data base not sufficient for the assessment of criterion D1C3 for this species.	There are as yet no operational indicators to assess the spread of species (criterion D1C4) and the condition of habitats (criterion D1C5).	There are as yet no operational indicators to assess the spread of species (criterion D1C4) and the condition of habitats (criterion D1C5).			Data base not sufficient for the assessment of criterion D1C3 for this species.	There are as yet no operational indicators to assess the spread of species (criterion D1C4) and the condition of habitats (criterion D1C5).	There are as yet no operational indicators to assess the spread of species (criterion D1C4) and the condition of habitats (criterion D1C5).		There are as yet no operational indicators to assess the spread of species (criterion D1C4) and the condition of habitats (criterion D1C5).	There are as yet no operational indicators to assess the spread of species (criterion D1C4) and the condition of habitats (criterion D1C5).				There are as yet no operational indicators to assess the spread of species (criterion D1C4) and the condition of habitats (criterion D1C5).	There are as yet no operational indicators to assess the spread of species (criterion D1C4) and the condition of habitats (criterion D1C5).		There are as yet no operational indicators to assess the spread of species (criterion D1C4) and the condition of habitats (criterion D1C5).	There are as yet no operational indicators to assess the spread of species (criterion D1C4) and the condition of habitats (criterion D1C5).		There are as yet no operational indicators to assess the spread of species (criterion D1C4) and the condition of habitats (criterion D1C5).	There are as yet no operational indicators to assess the spread of species (criterion D1C4) and the condition of habitats (criterion D1C5).				There are as yet no operational indicators to assess the spread of species (criterion D1C4) and the condition of habitats (criterion D1C5).	There are as yet no operational indicators to assess the spread of species (criterion D1C4) and the condition of habitats (criterion D1C5).			Data base not sufficient for the assessment of criterion D1C3 for this species.	There are as yet no operational indicators to assess the spread of species (criterion D1C4) and the condition of habitats (criterion D1C5).	There are as yet no operational indicators to assess the spread of species (criterion D1C4) and the condition of habitats (criterion D1C5).		There are as yet no operational indicators to assess the spread of species (criterion D1C4) and the condition of habitats (criterion D1C5).	There are as yet no operational indicators to assess the spread of species (criterion D1C4) and the condition of habitats (criterion D1C5).		There are as yet no operational indicators to assess the spread of species (criterion D1C4) and the condition of habitats (criterion D1C5).	There are as yet no operational indicators to assess the spread of species (criterion D1C4) and the condition of habitats (criterion D1C5).			Data base not sufficient for the assessment of criterion D1C3 for this species.	There are as yet no operational indicators to assess the spread of species (criterion D1C4) and the condition of habitats (criterion D1C5).	There are as yet no operational indicators to assess the spread of species (criterion D1C4) and the condition of habitats (criterion D1C5).			Data base not sufficient for the assessment of criterion D1C3 for this species.	There are as yet no operational indicators to assess the spread of species (criterion D1C4) and the condition of habitats (criterion D1C5).	There are as yet no operational indicators to assess the spread of species (criterion D1C4) and the condition of habitats (criterion D1C5).
Element status	Good					Not good						Good				Good				Good				Good				Good			Good					Not assessed				Good				Good				Not good						Good						Good						Good						Not good						Not assessed			Not good							Not good							Good						Not good							Good				Not good						Not good						Not assessed			Not assessed			Not assessed			Not good					Not good					Not good						Good					Not good				Good			Good				Good			Not good			Not good					Good					Not good					Good			Not good					Not good					Good			Good					Good			Good			Not good					Good					Not good			Good			Not good					Not good
Description element	The primary criterion D1C3 is not relevant for the assessment of this species in the marine area considered here.											The primary criterion D1C1 is not relevant for the assessment of this species in the marine area considered here.				The primary criterion D1C1 is not relevant for the assessment of this species in the marine area considered here.				The primary criterion D1C1 is not relevant for the assessment of this species in the marine area considered here.				The primary criterion D1C1 is not relevant for the assessment of this species in the marine area considered here.				The primary criteria D1C1 and D1C3 are not relevant for the assessment of this species in the marine area considered here.								It is not possible to assess the species due to poor data. The primary criterion D1C3 is not relevant for the assessment of this species in the marine area considered here.				The primary criterion D1C1 is not relevant for the assessment of this species in the marine area considered here.				The primary criterion D1C1 is not relevant for the assessment of this species in the marine area considered here.																																		Not a sufficient basis for the assessment of this type of assessment. The primary criteria D1C1 and D1C3 are not relevant for the assessment of this species in the marine area considered here.																														The primary criterion D1C1 is not relevant for the assessment of this species in the marine area considered here.				The primary criterion D1C1 is not relevant for the assessment of this species in the marine area considered here.												Insufficient data basis for the assessment of this species. The primary criteria D1C1 and D1C3 are not relevant for the assessment of this species in the marine area considered here.			Not a sufficient basis for the assessment of this type of assessment. The primary criteria D1C1 and D1C3 are not relevant for the assessment of this species in the marine area considered here.			Not a sufficient basis for the assessment of this type of assessment. The primary criteria D1C1 and D1C3 are not relevant for the assessment of this species in the marine area considered here.																								The primary criterion D1C1 is not relevant for the assessment of this species in the marine area considered here.				The primary criteria D1C1 and D1C3 are not relevant for the assessment of this species in the marine area considered here.			The primary criterion D1C1 is not relevant for the assessment of this species in the marine area considered here.				The primary criteria D1C1 and D1C3 are not relevant for the assessment of this species in the marine area considered here.			The primary criteria D1C1 and D1C3 are not relevant for the assessment of this species in the marine area considered here.			The primary criterion D1C1 is not relevant for the assessment of this species in the marine area considered here.					The primary criterion D1C1 is not relevant for the assessment of this species in the marine area considered here.					The primary criterion D1C1 is not relevant for the assessment of this species in the marine area considered here.					The primary criterion D1C1 is not relevant for the assessment of this species in the marine area considered here.			The primary criterion D1C1 is not relevant for the assessment of this species in the marine area considered here.					The primary criterion D1C1 is not relevant for the assessment of this species in the marine area considered here.					The primary criteria D1C1 and D1C3 are not relevant for the assessment of this species in the marine area considered here.			The primary criterion D1C1 is not relevant for the assessment of this species in the marine area considered here.					The primary criteria D1C1 and D1C3 are not relevant for the assessment of this species in the marine area considered here.			The primary criteria D1C1 and D1C3 are not relevant for the assessment of this species in the marine area considered here.			The primary criterion D1C1 is not relevant for the assessment of this species in the marine area considered here.					The primary criterion D1C1 is not relevant for the assessment of this species in the marine area considered here.					The primary criteria D1C1 and D1C3 are not relevant for the assessment of this species in the marine area considered here.			The primary criteria D1C1 and D1C3 are not relevant for the assessment of this species in the marine area considered here.			The primary criterion D1C1 is not relevant for the assessment of this species in the marine area considered here.					The primary criterion D1C1 is not relevant for the assessment of this species in the marine area considered here.
Integration rule type parameter	OOAO											OOAO																			OOAO																																									OOAO																																																																OOAO
Integration rule description parameter
Integration rule type criteria	OOAO											OOAO																			OOAO																																									OOAO																																																																OOAO
Integration rule description criteria	The criteria were assessed at the level of individual species. A species is in good condition if all criteria meet the relevant thresholds. At the level of the groups of species, the criteria are no longer taken into account.											The criteria were assessed at the level of individual species. A species is in good condition if all criteria meet the relevant thresholds. At the level of the groups of species, the criteria are no longer taken into account.																			The criteria were assessed at the level of individual species. A species is in good condition if all criteria meet the relevant thresholds. At the level of the groups of species, the criteria are no longer taken into account.																																									The criteria were assessed at the level of individual species. A species is in good condition if all criteria meet the relevant thresholds. At the level of the groups of species, the criteria are no longer taken into account.																																																																The criteria were assessed at the level of individual species. A species is in good condition if all criteria meet the relevant thresholds. At the level of the groups of species, the criteria are no longer taken into account.
GES extent threshold	75.00											75.00																			75.00																																									75.00																																																																75.00
GES extent achieved	50.00											100.00																			86.00																																									25.00																																																																52.38
GES extent unit	Proportion of species in good status within species group											Proportion of species in good status within species group																			Proportion of species in good status within species group																																									Proportion of species in good status within species group																																																																Proportion of species in good status within species group
GES achieved	GES expected to be achieved later than 2020, no Article 14 exception reported											GES achieved																			GES achieved																																									GES expected to be achieved later than 2020, no Article 14 exception reported																																																																GES expected to be achieved later than 2020, no Article 14 exception reported
Description overall status	For the assessment of the species groups, OSPAR used indicators for ?abundance of sea and coastal birds? and ?sea and coastal bird hatching or failure? and the related thresholds, partly supplemented by trend data for other species of the Wadden Sea with data from TWSC monitoring. If 75 % of the birds of a functional group reach a good status, the group is rated as ?good?.											For the assessment of the species groups, OSPAR used indicators for ?abundance of sea and coastal birds? and ?sea and coastal bird hatching or failure? and the related thresholds, partly supplemented by trend data for other species of the Wadden Sea with data from TWSC monitoring. If 75 % of the birds of a functional group reach a good status, the group is rated as ?good?.																			For the assessment of the species groups, OSPAR used indicators for ?abundance of sea and coastal birds? and ?sea and coastal bird hatching or failure? and the related thresholds, partly supplemented by trend data for other species of the Wadden Sea with data from TWSC monitoring. If 75 % of the birds of a functional group reach a good status, the group is rated as ?good?.																																									For the assessment of the species groups, OSPAR used indicators for ?abundance of sea and coastal birds? and ?sea and coastal bird hatching or failure? and the related thresholds, partly supplemented by trend data for other species of the Wadden Sea with data from TWSC monitoring. If 75 % of the birds of a functional group reach a good status, the group is rated as ?good?.																																																																For the assessment of the species groups, OSPAR used indicators for ?abundance of sea and coastal birds? and ?sea and coastal bird hatching or failure? and the related thresholds, partly supplemented by trend data for other species of the Wadden Sea with data from TWSC monitoring. If 75 % of the birds of a functional group reach a good status, the group is rated as ?good?.
Assessments period	2012-2018											2012-2018																			2012-2018																																									2012-2018																																																																2012-2018
Related pressures	All pressures related to inputs of substances, litter and energy Disturbance of species (e.g. where they breed, rest and feed) due to human presence Extraction of, or mortality/injury to, wild species (by commercial and recreational fishing and other activities)											All pressures related to inputs of substances, litter and energy Disturbance of species (e.g. where they breed, rest and feed) due to human presence Extraction of, or mortality/injury to, wild species (by commercial and recreational fishing and other activities)																			All pressures related to inputs of substances, litter and energy Disturbance of species (e.g. where they breed, rest and feed) due to human presence Extraction of, or mortality/injury to, wild species (by commercial and recreational fishing and other activities)																																									All pressures related to inputs of substances, litter and energy Disturbance of species (e.g. where they breed, rest and feed) due to human presence Extraction of, or mortality/injury to, wild species (by commercial and recreational fishing and other activities)																																																																All pressures related to inputs of substances, litter and energy Disturbance of species (e.g. where they breed, rest and feed) due to human presence Extraction of, or mortality/injury to, wild species (by commercial and recreational fishing and other activities)
Related targets	UZN2 UZN3.1 UZN3.2 UZN3.4 UZN4.3 UZN4.5 UZN4.6 UZN5											UZN2 UZN3.1 UZN3.2 UZN3.4 UZN4.3 UZN4.5 UZN4.6 UZN5																			UZN2 UZN3.1 UZN3.2 UZN3.4 UZN4.3 UZN4.5 UZN4.6 UZN5																																									UZN2 UZN3.1 UZN3.2 UZN3.4 UZN4.3 UZN4.5 UZN4.6 UZN5																																																																UZN2 UZN3.1 UZN3.2 UZN3.4 UZN4.3 UZN4.5 UZN4.6 UZN5