Art8-2024

Member State report / Art8-2024 / 2024 / D11 / Estonia / Baltic Sea

Report type	Member State report to Commission
MSFD Article	Art8
Report due	2024-10-15
GES Descriptor	D11 Energy, incl. underwater noise
Member State	Estonia
Region/subregion	Baltic Sea
Report date	2024-12-11 14:54:57

BAL-EE-AA-EGB

Simplified table

Regional assessment area	HELCOML1_SEA000	HELCOML1_SEA000	HELCOML1_SEA000	HELCOML1_SEA000	HELCOML2_SEA-009	HELCOML2_SEA-009		HELCOML2_SEA-009		HELCOML2_SEA-009
Component MRUs
GES component	D11	D11	D11	D11	D11	D11	D11	D11	D11	D11
Feature	Impulsive sound in water	Impulsive sound in water	Impulsive sound in water	Impulsive sound in water	Continuous low frequency sound	Continuous low frequency sound	Continuous low frequency sound	Continuous low frequency sound	Continuous low frequency sound	Continuous low frequency sound
Element			Impulsive sound in water	Impulsive sound in water			Continuous low frequency sound	Continuous low frequency sound	Continuous low frequency sound	Continuous low frequency sound
Element extent
Trend element			Unknown	Unknown				Unknown		Unknown
Element 2							Clupea harengus	Clupea harengus	Mammals	Mammals
Element source			EU;HELCOM;MSFD 2017 Decision	EU;HELCOM;MSFD 2017 Decision				EU;HELCOM;MSFD 2017 Decision		EU;HELCOM;MSFD 2017 Decision
Criterion	D11C1	D11C1	D11C1	D11C1	D11C2	D11C2	D11C2	D11C2	D11C2	D11C2
Parameter	EXP-HAB-DAY	EXP-HAB-YR	EXP-HAB-DAY	EXP-HAB-YR	EXP-HAB (125 Hz)	EXP-HAB (500Hz)		EXP-HAB (125 Hz)		EXP-HAB (500Hz)
Threshold value upper
Threshold value lower
Threshold value operator	<=	<=	<=	<=	<=	<=		<=		<=
Threshold qualitative					110 dB re 1 µPa	110 dB re 1 µPa		110 dB re 1 µPa		110 dB re 1 µPa
Threshold value source	EU;HELCOM	EU;HELCOM	EU;HELCOM	EU;HELCOM	EU;HELCOM	EU;HELCOM		EU;HELCOM		EU;HELCOM
Value achieved upper
Value achieved lower
Value unit
Proportion threshold value	20.0	10.0	20.0	10.0	20.0	20.0		20.0		20.0
Proportion value achieved	6.0		6.0		71.0			71.0
Proportion threshold value unit	% area of habitat adversely affected	% area of habitat adversely affected	% area of habitat adversely affected	% area of habitat adversely affected	% area of habitat adversely affected	% area of habitat adversely affected		% area of habitat adversely affected		% area of habitat adversely affected
Trend parameter	Unknown	Unknown	Unknown	Unknown	Unknown	Unknown		Unknown		Unknown
Parameter achieved	Yes	Yes	Yes	Yes	No	Yes		No		Yes
Description parameter	A maximum fraction of 20% or lower over 1 day of the habitat to be exposed to impulsive noise levels higher than LOBE	A maximum of 10% or lower over 1 year on average of the habitat to be exposed to impulsive noise levels higher than LOBE	A maximum fraction of 20% or lower over 1 day of the habitat to be exposed to impulsive noise levels higher than LOBE	A maximum of 10% or lower over 1 year on average of the habitat to be exposed to impulsive noise levels higher than LOBE	Disturbance thresholds (110 dB re 1 µPa) do not exceed more than 50% of the time in more than 20% of the assessment area in the 125 Hz decidecade band	Disturbance thresholds (110 dB re 1 µPa) do not exceed more than 50% of the time in more than 20% of the assessment area in the 500 Hz decidecade band		Disturbance thresholds (110 dB re 1 µPa) do not exceed more than 50% of the time in more than 20% of the assessment area in the 125 Hz decidecade band		Disturbance thresholds (110 dB re 1 µPa) do not exceed more than 50% of the time in more than 20% of the assessment area in the 500 Hz decidecade band
Related indicator	BALEED11C1.1	BALEED11C1.1	BALEED11C1.1	BALEED11C1.1	BALEED11C2.1	BALEED11C2.2		BALEED11C2.1		BALEED11C2.2
Criteria status	Good	Good			Not good	Not good
Description criteria					GES is considered achieved if it is achieved for each assessed species or species group. The assessment showed that the continuous noise indicator exceeded threshold for fish	GES is considered achieved if it is achieved for each assessed species or species group. The assessment showed that the continuous noise indicator exceeded threshold for fish	Evaluation of noise effects on species: fish (Clupea harengus)	Evaluation of noise effects on species: fish (Clupea harengus)	Evaluation of noise effects on species: marine mammals (seals)	Evaluation of noise effects on species: marine mammals (seals)
Element status			Good	Good				Not good		Good
Description element								Evaluation of noise effects on species: fish (Clupea harengus)		Evaluation of noise effects on species: marine mammals (seals)
Source assessment feature	EU HELCOM	EU HELCOM	EU HELCOM	EU HELCOM	EU HELCOM	EU HELCOM		EU HELCOM		EU HELCOM
Reporting method feature	Type B2	Type B2	Type B2	Type B2	Type B2	Type B2		Type B2		Type B2
Trend feature	Unknown	Unknown	Unknown	Unknown	Unknown	Unknown		Unknown		Unknown
Integration rule type parameter	OOAO	OOAO	OOAO	OOAO	OOAO	OOAO		OOAO		OOAO
Integration rule description parameter	Both daily and annual parameters to be achieved for D11C1	Both daily and annual parameters to be achieved for D11C1	Both daily and annual parameters to be achieved for D11C1	Both daily and annual parameters to be achieved for D11C1	Parameters to be achieved for each species or species group assessed	Parameters to be achieved for each species or species group assessed		Parameters to be achieved for each species or species group assessed		Parameters to be achieved for each species or species group assessed
Integration rule type criteria	Not relevant	Not relevant	Not relevant	Not relevant	Not relevant	Not relevant		Not relevant		Not relevant
Integration rule description criteria
GES extent threshold	100.00	100.00	100.00	100.00	100.00	100.00		100.00		100.00
GES extent achieved	100.00	100.00	100.00	100.00
GES extent unit	Proportion of area in good status	Proportion of area in good status	Proportion of area in good status	Proportion of area in good status	Proportion of area in good status	Proportion of area in good status		Proportion of area in good status		Proportion of area in good status
GES achieved	GES achieved by 2024	GES achieved by 2024	GES achieved by 2024	GES achieved by 2024	GES later than 2024, Art14ExceptionNotReported	GES later than 2024, Art14ExceptionNotReported		GES later than 2024, Art14ExceptionNotReported		GES later than 2024, Art14ExceptionNotReported
Description overall status					GES is considered achieved for the entire area if it is achieved for each assessed species or species group. The assessment showed that the continuous noise indicator exceeded the 20% spatial threshold for fish	GES is considered achieved for the entire area if it is achieved for each assessed species or species group. The assessment showed that the continuous noise indicator exceeded the 20% spatial threshold for fish		GES is considered achieved for the entire area if it is achieved for each assessed species or species group. The assessment showed that the continuous noise indicator exceeded the 20% spatial threshold for fish		GES is considered achieved for the entire area if it is achieved for each assessed species or species group. The assessment showed that the continuous noise indicator exceeded the 20% spatial threshold for fish
Assessments period	2016-2021	2016-2021	2016-2021	2016-2021	2016-2021	2016-2021		2016-2021		2016-2021
Related pressures	Input of anthropogenic sound (impulsive, continuous)	Input of anthropogenic sound (impulsive, continuous)	Input of anthropogenic sound (impulsive, continuous)	Input of anthropogenic sound (impulsive, continuous)	Input of anthropogenic sound (impulsive, continuous)	Input of anthropogenic sound (impulsive, continuous)		Input of anthropogenic sound (impulsive, continuous)		Input of anthropogenic sound (impulsive, continuous)
Related targets	BALEE-T37 BALEE-T38 BALEE-T39 BALEE-T41 BALEE-T43 BALEE-T46 BALEE-T54	BALEE-T37 BALEE-T38 BALEE-T39 BALEE-T41 BALEE-T43 BALEE-T46 BALEE-T54	BALEE-T37 BALEE-T38 BALEE-T39 BALEE-T41 BALEE-T43 BALEE-T46 BALEE-T54	BALEE-T37 BALEE-T38 BALEE-T39 BALEE-T41 BALEE-T43 BALEE-T46 BALEE-T54	BALEE-T37 BALEE-T38 BALEE-T39 BALEE-T41 BALEE-T43 BALEE-T44 BALEE-T45 BALEE-T54	BALEE-T37 BALEE-T38 BALEE-T39 BALEE-T41 BALEE-T43 BALEE-T44 BALEE-T45 BALEE-T54		BALEE-T37 BALEE-T38 BALEE-T39 BALEE-T41 BALEE-T43 BALEE-T44 BALEE-T45 BALEE-T54		BALEE-T37 BALEE-T38 BALEE-T39 BALEE-T41 BALEE-T43 BALEE-T44 BALEE-T45 BALEE-T54
Test TV	NA	NA	NA	NA	NA	NA	NA	NA	NA	NA
Test results	False	False	False	False	False	False	False	False	False	False

BAL-EE-AA-GF

Simplified table

Regional assessment area	HELCOML1_SEA000	HELCOML1_SEA000	HELCOML1_SEA000	HELCOML1_SEA000	HELCOML2_SEA-013	HELCOML2_SEA-013		HELCOML2_SEA-013		HELCOML2_SEA-013
Component MRUs
GES component	D11	D11	D11	D11	D11	D11	D11	D11	D11	D11
Feature	Impulsive sound in water	Impulsive sound in water	Impulsive sound in water	Impulsive sound in water	Continuous low frequency sound	Continuous low frequency sound	Continuous low frequency sound	Continuous low frequency sound	Continuous low frequency sound	Continuous low frequency sound
Element			Impulsive sound in water	Impulsive sound in water			Continuous low frequency sound	Continuous low frequency sound	Continuous low frequency sound	Continuous low frequency sound
Element extent
Trend element			Unknown	Unknown				Unknown		Unknown
Element 2							Clupea harengus	Clupea harengus	Mammals	Mammals
Element source			EU;HELCOM;MSFD 2017 Decision	EU;HELCOM;MSFD 2017 Decision				EU;HELCOM;MSFD 2017 Decision		EU;HELCOM;MSFD 2017 Decision
Criterion	D11C1	D11C1	D11C1	D11C1	D11C2	D11C2	D11C2	D11C2	D11C2	D11C2
Parameter	EXP-HAB-DAY	EXP-HAB-YR	EXP-HAB-DAY	EXP-HAB-YR	EXP-HAB (125 Hz)	EXP-HAB (500Hz)		EXP-HAB (125 Hz)		EXP-HAB (500Hz)
Threshold value upper
Threshold value lower
Threshold value operator	<=	<=	<=	<=	<=	<=		<=		<=
Threshold qualitative					110 dB re 1 µPa	110 dB re 1 µPa		110 dB re 1 µPa		110 dB re 1 µPa
Threshold value source	EU;HELCOM	EU;HELCOM	EU;HELCOM	EU;HELCOM	EU;HELCOM	EU;HELCOM		EU;HELCOM		EU;HELCOM
Value achieved upper
Value achieved lower
Value unit
Proportion threshold value	20.0	10.0	20.0	10.0	20.0	20.0		20.0		20.0
Proportion value achieved	16.0		16.0		51.0	19.0		51.0		19.0
Proportion threshold value unit	% area of habitat adversely affected	% area of habitat adversely affected	% area of habitat adversely affected	% area of habitat adversely affected	% area of habitat adversely affected	% area of habitat adversely affected		% area of habitat adversely affected		% area of habitat adversely affected
Trend parameter	Unknown	Unknown	Unknown	Unknown	Unknown	Unknown		Unknown		Unknown
Parameter achieved	Yes	Yes	Yes	Yes	No	Yes		No		Yes
Description parameter	A maximum fraction of 20% or lower over 1 day of the habitat to be exposed to impulsive noise levels higher than LOBE	A maximum of 10% or lower over 1 year on average of the habitat to be exposed to impulsive noise levels higher than LOBE	A maximum fraction of 20% or lower over 1 day of the habitat to be exposed to impulsive noise levels higher than LOBE	A maximum of 10% or lower over 1 year on average of the habitat to be exposed to impulsive noise levels higher than LOBE	Disturbance thresholds (110 dB re 1 µPa) do not exceed more than 50% of the time in more than 20% of the assessment area in the 125 Hz decidecade band	Disturbance thresholds (110 dB re 1 µPa) do not exceed more than 50% of the time in more than 20% of the assessment area in the 500 Hz decidecade band		Disturbance thresholds (110 dB re 1 µPa) do not exceed more than 50% of the time in more than 20% of the assessment area in the 125 Hz decidecade band		Disturbance thresholds (110 dB re 1 µPa) do not exceed more than 50% of the time in more than 20% of the assessment area in the 500 Hz decidecade band
Related indicator	BALEED11C1.1	BALEED11C1.1	BALEED11C1.1	BALEED11C1.1	BALEED11C2.1	BALEED11C2.2		BALEED11C2.1		BALEED11C2.2
Criteria status	Good	Good			Not good	Not good
Description criteria					GES is considered achieved if it is achieved for each assessed species or species group. The assessment showed that the continuous noise indicator exceeded threshold for fish	GES is considered achieved if it is achieved for each assessed species or species group. The assessment showed that the continuous noise indicator exceeded threshold for fish	Evaluation of noise effects on species: fish (Clupea harengus)	Evaluation of noise effects on species: fish (Clupea harengus)	Evaluation of noise effects on species: marine mammals (seals)	Evaluation of noise effects on species: marine mammals (seals)
Element status			Good	Good				Not good		Good
Description element								Evaluation of noise effects on species: fish (Clupea harengus)		Evaluation of noise effects on species: marine mammals (seals)
Source assessment feature	EU HELCOM	EU HELCOM	EU HELCOM	EU HELCOM	EU HELCOM	EU HELCOM		EU HELCOM		EU HELCOM
Reporting method feature	Type B2	Type B2	Type B2	Type B2	Type B2	Type B2		Type B2		Type B2
Trend feature	Unknown	Unknown	Unknown	Unknown	Unknown	Unknown		Unknown		Unknown
Integration rule type parameter	OOAO	OOAO	OOAO	OOAO	OOAO	OOAO		OOAO		OOAO
Integration rule description parameter	Both daily and annual parameters to be achieved for D11C1	Both daily and annual parameters to be achieved for D11C1	Both daily and annual parameters to be achieved for D11C1	Both daily and annual parameters to be achieved for D11C1	Parameters to be achieved for each species or species group assessed	Parameters to be achieved for each species or species group assessed		Parameters to be achieved for each species or species group assessed		Parameters to be achieved for each species or species group assessed
Integration rule type criteria	Not relevant	Not relevant	Not relevant	Not relevant	Not relevant	Not relevant		Not relevant		Not relevant
Integration rule description criteria
GES extent threshold	100.00	100.00	100.00	100.00	100.00	100.00		100.00		100.00
GES extent achieved	100.00	100.00	100.00	100.00
GES extent unit	Proportion of area in good status	Proportion of area in good status	Proportion of area in good status	Proportion of area in good status	Proportion of area in good status	Proportion of area in good status		Proportion of area in good status		Proportion of area in good status
GES achieved	GES achieved by 2024	GES achieved by 2024	GES achieved by 2024	GES achieved by 2024	GES later than 2024, Art14ExceptionNotReported	GES later than 2024, Art14ExceptionNotReported		GES later than 2024, Art14ExceptionNotReported		GES later than 2024, Art14ExceptionNotReported
Description overall status					GES is considered achieved for the entire area if it is achieved for each assessed species or species group. The assessment showed that the continuous noise indicator exceeded the 20% spatial threshold for fish	GES is considered achieved for the entire area if it is achieved for each assessed species or species group. The assessment showed that the continuous noise indicator exceeded the 20% spatial threshold for fish		GES is considered achieved for the entire area if it is achieved for each assessed species or species group. The assessment showed that the continuous noise indicator exceeded the 20% spatial threshold for fish		GES is considered achieved for the entire area if it is achieved for each assessed species or species group. The assessment showed that the continuous noise indicator exceeded the 20% spatial threshold for fish
Assessments period	2016-2021	2016-2021	2016-2021	2016-2021	2016-2021	2016-2021		2016-2021		2016-2021
Related pressures	Input of anthropogenic sound (impulsive, continuous)	Input of anthropogenic sound (impulsive, continuous)	Input of anthropogenic sound (impulsive, continuous)	Input of anthropogenic sound (impulsive, continuous)	Input of anthropogenic sound (impulsive, continuous)	Input of anthropogenic sound (impulsive, continuous)		Input of anthropogenic sound (impulsive, continuous)		Input of anthropogenic sound (impulsive, continuous)
Related targets	BALEE-T37 BALEE-T38 BALEE-T39 BALEE-T41 BALEE-T43 BALEE-T46 BALEE-T54	BALEE-T37 BALEE-T38 BALEE-T39 BALEE-T41 BALEE-T43 BALEE-T46 BALEE-T54	BALEE-T37 BALEE-T38 BALEE-T39 BALEE-T41 BALEE-T43 BALEE-T46 BALEE-T54	BALEE-T37 BALEE-T38 BALEE-T39 BALEE-T41 BALEE-T43 BALEE-T46 BALEE-T54	BALEE-T37 BALEE-T38 BALEE-T39 BALEE-T41 BALEE-T43 BALEE-T44 BALEE-T45 BALEE-T54	BALEE-T37 BALEE-T38 BALEE-T39 BALEE-T41 BALEE-T43 BALEE-T44 BALEE-T45 BALEE-T54		BALEE-T37 BALEE-T38 BALEE-T39 BALEE-T41 BALEE-T43 BALEE-T44 BALEE-T45 BALEE-T54		BALEE-T37 BALEE-T38 BALEE-T39 BALEE-T41 BALEE-T43 BALEE-T44 BALEE-T45 BALEE-T54
Test TV	NA	NA	NA	NA	NA	NA	NA	NA	NA	NA
Test results	False	False	False	False	False	False	False	False	False	False

BAL-EE-AA-GR

Simplified table

Regional assessment area	HELCOML1_SEA000	HELCOML1_SEA000	HELCOML1_SEA000	HELCOML1_SEA000	HELCOML2_SEA-011	HELCOML2_SEA-011		HELCOML2_SEA-011		HELCOML2_SEA-011
Component MRUs
GES component	D11	D11	D11	D11	D11	D11	D11	D11	D11	D11
Feature	Impulsive sound in water	Impulsive sound in water	Impulsive sound in water	Impulsive sound in water	Continuous low frequency sound	Continuous low frequency sound	Continuous low frequency sound	Continuous low frequency sound	Continuous low frequency sound	Continuous low frequency sound
Element			Impulsive sound in water	Impulsive sound in water			Continuous low frequency sound	Continuous low frequency sound	Continuous low frequency sound	Continuous low frequency sound
Element extent
Trend element			Unknown	Unknown				Unknown		Unknown
Element 2							Clupea harengus	Clupea harengus	Mammals	Mammals
Element source			EU;HELCOM;MSFD 2017 Decision	EU;HELCOM;MSFD 2017 Decision				EU;HELCOM;MSFD 2017 Decision		EU;HELCOM;MSFD 2017 Decision
Criterion	D11C1	D11C1	D11C1	D11C1	D11C2	D11C2	D11C2	D11C2	D11C2	D11C2
Parameter	EXP-HAB-DAY	EXP-HAB-YR	EXP-HAB-DAY	EXP-HAB-YR	EXP-HAB (125 Hz)	EXP-HAB (500Hz)		EXP-HAB (125 Hz)		EXP-HAB (500Hz)
Threshold value upper
Threshold value lower
Threshold value operator	<=	<=	<=	<=	<=	<=		<=		<=
Threshold qualitative					110 dB re 1 µPa	110 dB re 1 µPa		110 dB re 1 µPa		110 dB re 1 µPa
Threshold value source	EU;HELCOM	EU;HELCOM	EU;HELCOM	EU;HELCOM	EU;HELCOM	EU;HELCOM		EU;HELCOM		EU;HELCOM
Value achieved upper
Value achieved lower
Value unit
Proportion threshold value	20.0	10.0	20.0	10.0	20.0	20.0		20.0		20.0
Proportion value achieved	10.0		10.0
Proportion threshold value unit	% area of habitat adversely affected	% area of habitat adversely affected	% area of habitat adversely affected	% area of habitat adversely affected	% area of habitat adversely affected	% area of habitat adversely affected		% area of habitat adversely affected		% area of habitat adversely affected
Trend parameter	Unknown	Unknown	Unknown	Unknown	Unknown	Unknown		Unknown		Unknown
Parameter achieved	Yes	Yes	Yes	Yes	Yes	Yes		Yes		Yes
Description parameter	A maximum fraction of 20% or lower over 1 day of the habitat to be exposed to impulsive noise levels higher than LOBE	A maximum of 10% or lower over 1 year on average of the habitat to be exposed to impulsive noise levels higher than LOBE	A maximum fraction of 20% or lower over 1 day of the habitat to be exposed to impulsive noise levels higher than LOBE	A maximum of 10% or lower over 1 year on average of the habitat to be exposed to impulsive noise levels higher than LOBE	Disturbance thresholds (110 dB re 1 µPa) do not exceed more than 50% of the time in more than 20% of the assessment area in the 125 Hz decidecade band	Disturbance thresholds (110 dB re 1 µPa) do not exceed more than 50% of the time in more than 20% of the assessment area in the 500 Hz decidecade band		Disturbance thresholds (110 dB re 1 µPa) do not exceed more than 50% of the time in more than 20% of the assessment area in the 125 Hz decidecade band		Disturbance thresholds (110 dB re 1 µPa) do not exceed more than 50% of the time in more than 20% of the assessment area in the 500 Hz decidecade band
Related indicator	BALEED11C1.1	BALEED11C1.1	BALEED11C1.1	BALEED11C1.1	BALEED11C2.1	BALEED11C2.2		BALEED11C2.1		BALEED11C2.2
Criteria status	Good	Good			Good	Good
Description criteria							Evaluation of noise effects on species: fish (Clupea harengus)	Evaluation of noise effects on species: fish (Clupea harengus)	Evaluation of noise effects on species: marine mammals (seals)	Evaluation of noise effects on species: marine mammals (seals)
Element status			Good	Good				Good		Good
Description element								Evaluation of noise effects on species: fish (Clupea harengus)		Evaluation of noise effects on species: marine mammals (seals)
Source assessment feature	EU HELCOM	EU HELCOM	EU HELCOM	EU HELCOM	EU HELCOM	EU HELCOM		EU HELCOM		EU HELCOM
Reporting method feature	Type B2	Type B2	Type B2	Type B2	Type B2	Type B2		Type B2		Type B2
Trend feature	Unknown	Unknown	Unknown	Unknown	Unknown	Unknown		Unknown		Unknown
Integration rule type parameter	OOAO	OOAO	OOAO	OOAO	OOAO	OOAO		OOAO		OOAO
Integration rule description parameter	Both daily and annual parameters to be achieved for D11C1	Both daily and annual parameters to be achieved for D11C1	Both daily and annual parameters to be achieved for D11C1	Both daily and annual parameters to be achieved for D11C1	Parameters to be achieved for each species or species group assessed	Parameters to be achieved for each species or species group assessed		Parameters to be achieved for each species or species group assessed		Parameters to be achieved for each species or species group assessed
Integration rule type criteria	Not relevant	Not relevant	Not relevant	Not relevant	Not relevant	Not relevant		Not relevant		Not relevant
Integration rule description criteria
GES extent threshold	100.00	100.00	100.00	100.00	100.00	100.00		100.00		100.00
GES extent achieved	100.00	100.00	100.00	100.00	100.00	100.00		100.00		100.00
GES extent unit	Proportion of area in good status	Proportion of area in good status	Proportion of area in good status	Proportion of area in good status	Proportion of area in good status	Proportion of area in good status		Proportion of area in good status		Proportion of area in good status
GES achieved	GES achieved by 2024	GES achieved by 2024	GES achieved by 2024	GES achieved by 2024	GES achieved by 2024	GES achieved by 2024		GES achieved by 2024		GES achieved by 2024
Description overall status
Assessments period	2016-2021	2016-2021	2016-2021	2016-2021	2016-2021	2016-2021		2016-2021		2016-2021
Related pressures	Input of anthropogenic sound (impulsive, continuous)	Input of anthropogenic sound (impulsive, continuous)	Input of anthropogenic sound (impulsive, continuous)	Input of anthropogenic sound (impulsive, continuous)	Input of anthropogenic sound (impulsive, continuous)	Input of anthropogenic sound (impulsive, continuous)		Input of anthropogenic sound (impulsive, continuous)		Input of anthropogenic sound (impulsive, continuous)
Related targets	BALEE-T37 BALEE-T38 BALEE-T39 BALEE-T41 BALEE-T43 BALEE-T46 BALEE-T54	BALEE-T37 BALEE-T38 BALEE-T39 BALEE-T41 BALEE-T43 BALEE-T46 BALEE-T54	BALEE-T37 BALEE-T38 BALEE-T39 BALEE-T41 BALEE-T43 BALEE-T46 BALEE-T54	BALEE-T37 BALEE-T38 BALEE-T39 BALEE-T41 BALEE-T43 BALEE-T46 BALEE-T54	BALEE-T37 BALEE-T38 BALEE-T39 BALEE-T41 BALEE-T43 BALEE-T44 BALEE-T45 BALEE-T54	BALEE-T37 BALEE-T38 BALEE-T39 BALEE-T41 BALEE-T43 BALEE-T44 BALEE-T45 BALEE-T54		BALEE-T37 BALEE-T38 BALEE-T39 BALEE-T41 BALEE-T43 BALEE-T44 BALEE-T45 BALEE-T54		BALEE-T37 BALEE-T38 BALEE-T39 BALEE-T41 BALEE-T43 BALEE-T44 BALEE-T45 BALEE-T54
Test TV	NA	NA	NA	NA	NA	NA	NA	NA	NA	NA
Test results	False	False	False	False	False	False	False	False	False	False

BAL-EE-AA-NBP

Simplified table

Regional assessment area	HELCOML1_SEA000	HELCOML1_SEA000	HELCOML1_SEA000	HELCOML1_SEA000	HELCOML2_SEA-012	HELCOML2_SEA-012		HELCOML2_SEA-012		HELCOML2_SEA-012
Component MRUs
GES component	D11	D11	D11	D11	D11	D11	D11	D11	D11	D11
Feature	Impulsive sound in water	Impulsive sound in water	Impulsive sound in water	Impulsive sound in water	Continuous low frequency sound	Continuous low frequency sound	Continuous low frequency sound	Continuous low frequency sound	Continuous low frequency sound	Continuous low frequency sound
Element			Impulsive sound in water	Impulsive sound in water			Continuous low frequency sound	Continuous low frequency sound	Continuous low frequency sound	Continuous low frequency sound
Element extent
Trend element			Unknown	Unknown				Unknown		Unknown
Element 2							Clupea harengus	Clupea harengus	Mammals	Mammals
Element source			EU;HELCOM;MSFD 2017 Decision	EU;HELCOM;MSFD 2017 Decision				EU;HELCOM;MSFD 2017 Decision		EU;HELCOM;MSFD 2017 Decision
Criterion	D11C1	D11C1	D11C1	D11C1	D11C2	D11C2	D11C2	D11C2	D11C2	D11C2
Parameter	EXP-HAB-DAY	EXP-HAB-YR	EXP-HAB-DAY	EXP-HAB-YR	EXP-HAB (125 Hz)	EXP-HAB (500Hz)		EXP-HAB (125 Hz)		EXP-HAB (500Hz)
Threshold value upper
Threshold value lower
Threshold value operator	<=	<=	<=	<=	<=	<=		<=		<=
Threshold qualitative					110 dB re 1 µPa	110 dB re 1 µPa		110 dB re 1 µPa		110 dB re 1 µPa
Threshold value source	EU;HELCOM	EU;HELCOM	EU;HELCOM	EU;HELCOM	EU;HELCOM	EU;HELCOM		EU;HELCOM		EU;HELCOM
Value achieved upper
Value achieved lower
Value unit
Proportion threshold value	20.0	10.0	20.0	10.0	20.0	20.0		20.0		20.0
Proportion value achieved					79.0	1.0		79.0		1.0
Proportion threshold value unit	% area of habitat adversely affected	% area of habitat adversely affected	% area of habitat adversely affected	% area of habitat adversely affected	% area of habitat adversely affected	% area of habitat adversely affected		% area of habitat adversely affected		% area of habitat adversely affected
Trend parameter	Unknown	Unknown	Unknown	Unknown	Unknown	Unknown		Unknown		Unknown
Parameter achieved	Yes	Yes	Yes	Yes	No	Yes		No		Yes
Description parameter	A maximum fraction of 20% or lower over 1 day of the habitat to be exposed to impulsive noise levels higher than LOBE	A maximum of 10% or lower over 1 year on average of the habitat to be exposed to impulsive noise levels higher than LOBE	A maximum fraction of 20% or lower over 1 day of the habitat to be exposed to impulsive noise levels higher than LOBE	A maximum of 10% or lower over 1 year on average of the habitat to be exposed to impulsive noise levels higher than LOBE	Disturbance thresholds (110 dB re 1 µPa) do not exceed more than 50% of the time in more than 20% of the assessment area in the 125 Hz decidecade band	Disturbance thresholds (110 dB re 1 µPa) do not exceed more than 50% of the time in more than 20% of the assessment area in the 500 Hz decidecade band		Disturbance thresholds (110 dB re 1 µPa) do not exceed more than 50% of the time in more than 20% of the assessment area in the 125 Hz decidecade band		Disturbance thresholds (110 dB re 1 µPa) do not exceed more than 50% of the time in more than 20% of the assessment area in the 500 Hz decidecade band
Related indicator	BALEED11C1.1	BALEED11C1.1	BALEED11C1.1	BALEED11C1.1	BALEED11C2.1	BALEED11C2.2		BALEED11C2.1		BALEED11C2.2
Criteria status	Good	Good			Not good	Not good
Description criteria					GES is considered achieved if it is achieved for each assessed species or species group. The assessment showed that the continuous noise indicator exceeded threshold for fish	GES is considered achieved if it is achieved for each assessed species or species group. The assessment showed that the continuous noise indicator exceeded threshold for fish	Evaluation of noise effects on species: fish (Clupea harengus)	Evaluation of noise effects on species: fish (Clupea harengus)	Evaluation of noise effects on species: marine mammals (seals)	Evaluation of noise effects on species: marine mammals (seals)
Element status			Good	Good				Not good		Good
Description element								Evaluation of noise effects on species: fish (Clupea harengus)		Evaluation of noise effects on species: marine mammals (seals)
Source assessment feature	EU HELCOM	EU HELCOM	EU HELCOM	EU HELCOM	EU HELCOM	EU HELCOM		EU HELCOM		EU HELCOM
Reporting method feature	Type B2	Type B2	Type B2	Type B2	Type B2	Type B2		Type B2		Type B2
Trend feature	Unknown	Unknown	Unknown	Unknown	Unknown	Unknown		Unknown		Unknown
Integration rule type parameter	OOAO	OOAO	OOAO	OOAO	OOAO	OOAO		OOAO		OOAO
Integration rule description parameter	Both daily and annual parameters to be achieved for D11C1	Both daily and annual parameters to be achieved for D11C1	Both daily and annual parameters to be achieved for D11C1	Both daily and annual parameters to be achieved for D11C1	Parameters to be achieved for each species or species group assessed	Parameters to be achieved for each species or species group assessed		Parameters to be achieved for each species or species group assessed		Parameters to be achieved for each species or species group assessed
Integration rule type criteria	Not relevant	Not relevant	Not relevant	Not relevant	Not relevant	Not relevant		Not relevant		Not relevant
Integration rule description criteria
GES extent threshold	100.00	100.00	100.00	100.00	100.00	100.00		100.00		100.00
GES extent achieved	100.00	100.00	100.00	100.00
GES extent unit	Proportion of area in good status	Proportion of area in good status	Proportion of area in good status	Proportion of area in good status	Proportion of area in good status	Proportion of area in good status		Proportion of area in good status		Proportion of area in good status
GES achieved	GES achieved by 2024	GES achieved by 2024	GES achieved by 2024	GES achieved by 2024	GES later than 2024, Art14ExceptionNotReported	GES later than 2024, Art14ExceptionNotReported		GES later than 2024, Art14ExceptionNotReported		GES later than 2024, Art14ExceptionNotReported
Description overall status					GES is considered achieved for the entire area if it is achieved for each assessed species or species group. The assessment showed that the continuous noise indicator exceeded the 20% spatial threshold for fish	GES is considered achieved for the entire area if it is achieved for each assessed species or species group. The assessment showed that the continuous noise indicator exceeded the 20% spatial threshold for fish		GES is considered achieved for the entire area if it is achieved for each assessed species or species group. The assessment showed that the continuous noise indicator exceeded the 20% spatial threshold for fish		GES is considered achieved for the entire area if it is achieved for each assessed species or species group. The assessment showed that the continuous noise indicator exceeded the 20% spatial threshold for fish
Assessments period	2016-2021	2016-2021	2016-2021	2016-2021	2016-2021	2016-2021		2016-2021		2016-2021
Related pressures	Input of anthropogenic sound (impulsive, continuous)	Input of anthropogenic sound (impulsive, continuous)	Input of anthropogenic sound (impulsive, continuous)	Input of anthropogenic sound (impulsive, continuous)	Input of anthropogenic sound (impulsive, continuous)	Input of anthropogenic sound (impulsive, continuous)		Input of anthropogenic sound (impulsive, continuous)		Input of anthropogenic sound (impulsive, continuous)
Related targets	BALEE-T37 BALEE-T38 BALEE-T39 BALEE-T41 BALEE-T43 BALEE-T46 BALEE-T54	BALEE-T37 BALEE-T38 BALEE-T39 BALEE-T41 BALEE-T43 BALEE-T46 BALEE-T54	BALEE-T37 BALEE-T38 BALEE-T39 BALEE-T41 BALEE-T43 BALEE-T46 BALEE-T54	BALEE-T37 BALEE-T38 BALEE-T39 BALEE-T41 BALEE-T43 BALEE-T46 BALEE-T54	BALEE-T37 BALEE-T38 BALEE-T39 BALEE-T41 BALEE-T43 BALEE-T44 BALEE-T45 BALEE-T54	BALEE-T37 BALEE-T38 BALEE-T39 BALEE-T41 BALEE-T43 BALEE-T44 BALEE-T45 BALEE-T54		BALEE-T37 BALEE-T38 BALEE-T39 BALEE-T41 BALEE-T43 BALEE-T44 BALEE-T45 BALEE-T54		BALEE-T37 BALEE-T38 BALEE-T39 BALEE-T41 BALEE-T43 BALEE-T44 BALEE-T45 BALEE-T54
Test TV	NA	NA	NA	NA	NA	NA	NA	NA	NA	NA
Test results	False	False	False	False	False	False	False	False	False	False