Member State report / Art9 / 2012 / D11 / North East Atlantic

Report type Member State report to Commission
MSFD Article Art. 9 Determination of GES (and Art. 17 updates)
Report due 2012-10-15
GES Descriptor D11 Energy, incl. underwater noise
Region/subregion North East Atlantic
Reported by Member state
Member state
SE (https://water.europa.eu/marine/assessment-module/national-descriptors-assessments/se/ans/d11/art9/@@view-report-data-2012)
DK (https://water.europa.eu/marine/assessment-module/national-descriptors-assessments/dk/ans/d11/art9/@@view-report-data-2012)
DE (https://water.europa.eu/marine/assessment-module/national-descriptors-assessments/de/ans/d11/art9/@@view-report-data-2012)
NL (https://water.europa.eu/marine/assessment-module/national-descriptors-assessments/nl/ans/d11/art9/@@view-report-data-2012)
BE (https://water.europa.eu/marine/assessment-module/national-descriptors-assessments/be/ans/d11/art9/@@view-report-data-2012)
FR (https://water.europa.eu/marine/assessment-module/national-descriptors-assessments/fr/ans/d11/art9/@@view-report-data-2012, https://water.europa.eu/marine/assessment-module/national-descriptors-assessments/fr/acs/d11/art9/@@view-report-data-2012, https://water.europa.eu/marine/assessment-module/national-descriptors-assessments/fr/abi/d11/art9/@@view-report-data-2012)
UK (https://water.europa.eu/marine/assessment-module/national-descriptors-assessments/uk/ans/d11/art9/@@view-report-data-2012, https://water.europa.eu/marine/assessment-module/national-descriptors-assessments/uk/acs/d11/art9/@@view-report-data-2012)
IE (https://water.europa.eu/marine/assessment-module/national-descriptors-assessments/ie/acs/d11/art9/@@view-report-data-2012)
ES (https://water.europa.eu/marine/assessment-module/national-descriptors-assessments/es/abi/d11/art9/@@view-report-data-2012, https://water.europa.eu/marine/assessment-module/national-descriptors-assessments/es/ama/d11/art9/@@view-report-data-2012)
PT (https://water.europa.eu/marine/assessment-module/national-descriptors-assessments/pt/abi/d11/art9/@@view-report-data-2012, https://water.europa.eu/marine/assessment-module/national-descriptors-assessments/pt/ama/d11/art9/@@view-report-data-2012)
Marine reporting units Number used
17
1
1
1
1
3
10
1
30
73
Features Functional group
BirdsOffshorePelagic (1)
BirdsOffshoreSurface (1)
CephalopodsCoastShelf (1)
CephalopodsDeep_sea (1)
FishDeep_sea (1)
FishDeep_seaElasmobranchs (1)
FishDemersal (1)
FishDemersalElasmobranchs (1)
FishPelagic (1)
FishPelagicElasmobranchs (1)
MammalsBaleenWhales (1)
MammalsSeals (1)
MammalsToothedWhales (1)
ReptilesTurtles (1)
FishDemersal (10)
FishDemersalElasmobranchs (6)
ReptilesTurtles (7)
GES description D11 Energy, incl. underwater noise
Tillförsel av energi, inbegripet undervattensbuller, ligger på nivåer som inte påverkar den marina miljön på ett negativt sätt.
Introduction of energy, including underwater noise, is at levels that do not adversely affect the marine environment.
A good environmental status is achieved if (1) the sound budget of the German North Sea does not adversely affect the living conditions of the animals concerned. All human noise-producing activities must therefore not have a significant impact on the marine environment of the North Sea. (2) The light input does not adversely affect marine life. (3) The emission of electromagnetic fields does not adversely affect migration or orientation of marine life. It is currently assumed that this will be achieved if, in the case of direct current, the measured values ​​on the sediment surface do not exceed the strength of the earth's magnetic field. (4) The rise in temperature does not have a negative impact on the marine environment. It is currently assumed that this will be achieved if the temperature increase does not exceed 2 K in the Wadden Sea at a depth of 30 cm or in the EEZ at a depth of 20 cm. For a more differentiated representation of the good environmental status with regard to these energy inputs, further research is required with regard to both the inputs and the effects. Indicator level. Light inputs: The lighting of structures necessary for the purpose of collision prevention can have a multitude of effects on marine life. For migrating birds, this light entry can e.g. lead to evasive movements and ultimately have a barrier effect. On the other hand, birds fly to illuminated objects, especially at night and when visibility is poor, so that attracting them can lead to an increase in bird strike. Electromagnetic fields: During the operation of electrical lines, magnetic fields are generated and electrical fields are induced. Electric fields are induced when either the sea water or the animal swimming in it moves in relation to the magnetic field (BfS, 2005). Temperature entries: Depending on the type of cable and the type of cable laid in the seabed, there can be a significant increase in temperature in the sediment and in the soil pore water , The jacket temperature for power cables is a maximum of 70 ° C. The release of this temperature to the environment depends on the type of cable, its utilization, the current sediment temperature as well as the heat capacity and the thermal conductivity of the sediment (BfS, 2005).
Introduction of energy, including underwater noise, is at levels that do not adversely affect the marine environment. Loud, low and mid frequency sounds and continuous low frequency sounds introduced into the marine environment through human activities do not have adverse effects on marine ecosystems.
Introduction of energy, including underwater noise, is at levels that do not adversely affect the marine environment.
Good ecological status is achieved when the following conditions are cumulatively met : - The detection and acoustic communication capacities of large cetaceans are not altered by anthropogenic noise disturbance; - The frequentation of ecological functional zones by species sensitive to noise disturbance is preserved; - The direct or indirect accidental excess mortality due to anthropogenic noise disturbance is marginal.


Good ecological status is achieved when the following conditions are cumulatively met : - The detection and acoustic communication capacities of large cetaceans are not altered by anthropogenic noise disturbance; - The frequentation of ecological functional zones by species sensitive to noise disturbance is preserved; - The direct or indirect accidental excess mortality due to anthropogenic noise disturbance is marginal.
"Loud, low and mid frequency impulsive sounds and continuous low frequency sounds introduced into the marine environment through human activities do not have adverse effects on marine ecosystems:

Human activities potentially introducing loud, low and mid frequency impulsive sounds into the marine environment are managed to the extent that no significant long term adverse effects are incurred at the population level or specifically to vulnerable/threatened species and key functional groups.

Continuous low frequency sound inputs do not pose a significant risk to marine life at the population level, or specifically to vulnerable/threatened species and key functional groups e.g. through the masking of biologically significant sounds and behavioural reactions

"
Loud, low and mid frequency impulsive sounds and continuous low frequency sounds introduced into the marine environment through human activities do not have adverse effects on marine ecosystems:

• Human activities introducing loud, low and mid-frequency impulsive sounds into the marine environment are managed to the extent that no significant long-term adverse effects are incurred at the population level, or specifically to vulnerable / threatened species and key functional groups.

• Continuous low frequency sound inputs do not pose a significant risk to marine life at the population level, or specifically to vulnerable / threatened species and key functional groups.
Para el actual ciclo de estrategias marinas, se propone definir el buen estado ambiental de acuerdo con lo acordado en el grupo ICG-MSFD de OSPAR (ver Documento Marco de Estrategias Marinas), con el siguiente enunciado: Los ruidos impulsivos de alta, media y baja frecuencia y el ruido continuo de baja frecuencia introducidos en el medio marino a través de las actividades humanas no tienen efectos adversos sobre los ecosistemas marinos.
GES description D11C1 Anthropogenic impulsive sound (11.1, 11.1.1)
Aktiviteter som skapar tillräckligt höga ljudnivåer för att orsaka negativa effekter för enskilda populationer eller ekosystem, begränsas i tid och rum.

11.1 Activities that create sound levels sufficiently high to cause adverse effects on individual populations or ecosystems are limited in time and space.
The introduction of energy, including underwater noise, is at levels that do not adversely affect the marine environment (Criterion D11.1.1).
A good environmental status is achieved if the sound budget of the German North Sea does not adversely affect the living conditions of the animals concerned. All human noise-producing activities must therefore not have a significant impact on the marine environment of the North Sea. Sound measurements during construction work in the sea are the possible basis for describing good conditions (Table 11 of the GES report North Sea). Temporary noise inputs in the form of impulsive signals should not cover any physical area Cause damage to marine organisms. According to the current state of knowledge, this means that a temporary hearing threshold shift (TTS) occurs at a SEL of 164 dB re 1micro; Pa2s (unweighted) with an associated SPL of 199 dB (peak-peak) re 1micro; Pa in porpoises. Perspectively, these sound entries must be viewed cumulatively in order to take account of multiple sound entries and different entry sources. Significant disturbance of marine fauna should be avoided, especially in protected areas and taking into account the occurrence of affected species and times sensitive to disturbances. There is currently no threshold for a significant disturbance for porpoises. On the basis of acoustic and visual examinations, however, it can be assumed that pulse-like underwater sound in sound events from a SEL of 136 dB re 1micro; Pa2s leads to disturbances in the form of displacement (BfN in development). This value was derived from observed displacement radii. Avoidance reactions of porpoises have been confirmed in playback experiments (Tougaard et al. 2011).
Impulsive sounds and regional sound budgets do not adversely impact marine organisms.
GES description D11C2 Anthropogenic continuous low-frequency sound (11.2, 11.2.1)
Undervattensbuller från fartyg ska inte ge upphov till långvariga negativa effekter på biologisk mångfald och ekosystem.

11.2 Underwater noise from ships must not give rise to long-lasting adverse effects on biological diversity and ecosystems.
A good environmental status is achieved if the sound budget of the German North Sea does not adversely affect the living conditions of the animals concerned. All human noise-producing activities must therefore not have a significant impact on the marine environment of the North Sea. Measurements of background noise values ​​(see Table 11 of the GES report North Sea) are a possible basis for describing a good state. Natural sound sources such as wind and wave motion form the background noise in the sea. In addition to this natural "acoustic landscape" there are anthropogenic continuous sound inputs, mainly from shipping. In addition, temporary impulsive noise inputs temporarily increase the noise level in a marine area. On the basis of knowledge of background noise levels specific to the sea area due to continuous, in particular low-frequency broadband noise, it must be decided to what extent a reduction should take place in order to prevent adverse effects on marine organisms.
Impulsive sounds and regional sound budgets do not adversely impact marine organisms.
Threshold values % of criteria with values (no. of criteria)
100.0% (3)
0.0% (1)
100.0% (3)
0.0% (1)
0.0% (3)
0.0% (3)
100.0% (2)
100.0% (1)
0.0% (3)
0.0% (0)
Proportion of area to achieve threshold values % of criteria with values (range of values reported)
100.0% (100 - 100)
0.0% (0 - 0)
0.0% (0 - 0)
0.0% (0 - 0)
0.0% (0 - 0)
0.0% (0 - 0)
100.0% (Not relevant - Not relevant)
100.0% (GES not yet quantitatively determined - GES not yet quantitatively determined)
0.0% (0 - 0)
0.0% (0 - 0)