Member State report / Art8 / 2018 / D4 / Denmark / NE Atlantic: Greater North Sea

Report type Member State report to Commission
MSFD Article Art. 8 Initial assessment (and Art. 17 updates)
Report due 2018-10-15
GES Descriptor D4 Food webs/D1 Ecosystems
Member State Denmark
Region/subregion NE Atlantic: Greater North Sea
Reported by Danish Environmental Protection Agency
Report date 2019-08-30
Report access DK_ART8_GES_Merge_20190829.xml

Danish part of Atlantic North Sea from coastline to EEZ (ANS-DK-TOTAL)

GES component
D4
D4
D4
D4
D4
D4
Feature
Shelf ecosystem
Shelf ecosystem
Shelf ecosystem
Shelf ecosystem
Shelf ecosystem
Shelf ecosystem
Element
Primary producers
Apex predators
Planktivores
Primary producers
Secondary producers
Sub-apex demersal predators
Element code
TrophicGuildsPrimProd
TrophicGuildsPredApex
TrophicGuildsPlankt
TrophicGuildsPrimProd
TrophicGuildsSecProd
TrophicGuildsPredSApexDem
Element code source
Link to other vocabulary or code lists that may be relevant
Link to other vocabulary or code lists that may be relevant
Link to other vocabulary or code lists that may be relevant
Link to other vocabulary or code lists that may be relevant
Link to other vocabulary or code lists that may be relevant
Link to other vocabulary or code lists that may be relevant
Element 2
Element 2 code
Element 2 code source
Element source
National
National
National
National
National
National
Criterion
D4C1
D4C2
D4C2
D4C2
D4C2
D4C2
Parameter
Other
Biomass
Biomass
Other
Other
Biomass
Parameter other
Diversity of primary producers see report in D1 pelagic habitats
Biomass as reported under D1 pelagic habitats
Biomass of zooplankton see report under D1 pelagic habitats.
Threshold value upper
Threshold value lower
Threshold qualitative
The diversity (species composition and their relative density) of the individual trophic levels is not negatively affected by man-made pressures.
The balance between the trophic levels (biomass or number of individuals).
The balance between the trophic levels (biomass or number of individuals).
The balance between the trophic levels (biomass or number of individuals).
Threshold value source
Threshold value source other
Value achieved upper
2000.0
60.0
Value achieved lower
30.0
Value unit
tonne
Other
Value unit other
mg C pr cubic meter
Proportion threshold value
Proportion value achieved
Proportion threshold value unit
Trend
Unknown
Stable
Unknown
Unknown
Unknown
Unknown
Parameter achieved
Unknown
Unknown
Unknown
Unknown
Unknown
Unknown
Description parameter
The distribution of phytoplankton shows large year-to-date fluctuations (see D1C6) but no trend over time. However, the number of species varies relatively little when calculated on the North Sea scale. For several of the trophic levels, the state of the individual species within the trophic level is known, but there is insufficient knowledge of the balance across and between the trophic levels. Therefore, regionally coordinated thresholds for the criteria under descriptor 4 are not currently set.
The above assessment covers the total biomass for the three species (gray seal, spotted seal and porpoise) from 2016. Of this, the biomass of guinea pigs is between 82-89%. For several of the trophic levels, the state of the individual species within the trophic level is known, but there is insufficient knowledge of the balance across and between the trophic levels. Therefore, regionally coordinated thresholds for the criteria under descriptor 4 are not currently set.
For several of the trophic levels, the state of the individual species within the trophic level is known, but there is insufficient knowledge of the balance across and between the trophic levels. Therefore, regionally coordinated thresholds for the criteria under descriptor 4 are not currently set.
Upper and lower values show the higher and lower annual mean values observed during the assessment period. Overall biomass of primary producers have been decreasing in the North Sea and Kattegat for the period 1978-2016, a slight increase has been observed since 2012.
There is no recognizable trend in the evolution of the zooplankton biomass since 2010 on the basis of a limited data base.
The biomass of large fish-eating fish (piscivore) around Denmark increased slightly in the period from 2010 to 2016 in the North Sea. The biomass of medium-sized pelagic fish around Denmark was at a high level in the period from 2010 to 2016, as the mackerel population has again increased after a period of low biomasses. This probably involves increased food competition with other planktivorous fish and increased mortality of herring, sand eel, sprat and cod. For several of the trophic levels, the state of the individual species within the trophic level is known, but there is insufficient knowledge of the balance across and between the trophic levels. Therefore, regionally coordinated thresholds for the criteria under descriptor 4 are not currently set.
Related indicator
Criteria status
Unknown
Unknown
Unknown
Unknown
Unknown
Unknown
Description criteria
The species diversity of phytoplankton exhibits large year-on-year fluctuations, but no trend over time. However, the number of species varies relatively little when calculated on the North Sea scale, and no temporal trends are still seen here. Overall, the species diversity of phytoplankton cannot be stated as being in good environmental condition, as the data base is currently too flimsy to be able to assess this.
The total marine mammal biomass is stable or increased from 1994 to 2016. The biomass in 2005 was lower than in 1994 (Figure 23.6). Porpoises make up 82-89% of the biomass all year, and the total figures for marine mammals are therefore mainly controlled by the biomass of harbour porpoises. The spotted seal has increased in number from 1994 to 2005 and from 2005 to 2016 in both areas. Gray seal was virtually absent in 1994 and 2005, but in 2016 the number has increased significantly in the MRU. Furthermore, according to the GES decision, good environmental status for seals and porpoises is considered to correspond to favorable conservation status under the Habitats Directive. Here, the condition of marine mammals in the Danish marine areas was assessed in 2013 under Article 17. It was considered that the condition of the spotted seal and porpoises in the North Sea and the Kattegat was favorable, while the condition of gray seal was unfavorable. On this basis, it is not possible to make an overall assessment of the state of the trophic level.
The biomass of small pelagic fish around Denmark has increased slightly in the period from 2010 to 2016, as both North Sea herring and North Sea sprat have increased. The food supply for predators on these species has thus been the site in recent years. Especially sprat is eaten by many birds and fish species.
The overall plankton biomass has been steadily declining in the North Sea and the Kattegat from 1978 to 2016. A slight increase is seen after 2012.
Data from the North Sea show that the proportion of zooplankton biomass exceeding 2000 μm in 2017 was below average for 2012-2015 and significantly below the highest value from 2014. Thus, the feeding conditions for both filtering (eg. herring) and particulate (e.g. sand eel) eating fish somewhat below average during the summer period in 2017. The time series is too short for trends to be described for longer periods.
The biomass of large fish-eating fish (piscivore) around Denmark increased slightly in the period from 2010 to 2016 in the North Sea. The biomass of medium-sized pelagic fish around Denmark was at a high level in the period from 2010 to 2016, as the mackerel population has again increased after a period of low biomasses. This probably involves increased food competition with other planktivorous fish and increased mortality of herring, sand eel, sprat and cod.
Element status
Unknown
Unknown
Unknown
Unknown
Unknown
Unknown
Description element
In a national inventory of marine mammals, three species are evaluated - harbour porpoise, spotted seal and gray seal. The condition of the marine mammals can often be seen as a good indicator of the overall state of the food chain, as the condition of this group of species is dependent on the condition of the underlying trophic levels.
This evaluation covers fish. Specifically the larger fisheating fish - in this evaluation populations of North Sea cod and North Sea saithe. Additionally medium fisheating fish which covers makrel in thei evaluation.
Integration rule type parameter
Not relevant
Not relevant
Not relevant
Not relevant
Not relevant
Not relevant
Integration rule description parameter
Integration has not been applied within trophic levels
Integration has not been applied within trophic levels
Integration has not been applied within trophic levels
Integration has not been applied within trophic levels
Integration has not been applied within trophic levels
Integration has not been applied within trophic levels
Integration rule type criteria
Not relevant
Not relevant
Not relevant
Not relevant
Not relevant
Not relevant
Integration rule description criteria
Integration has not been applied
Integration has not been applied
Integration has not been applied
Integration has not been applied
Integration has not been applied
Integration has not been applied
GES extent threshold
GES extent achieved
GES extent unit
GES achieved
Unknown
Unknown
Unknown
Unknown
Unknown
Unknown
Description overall status
The sea food network is dependent on the state of the different species groups, and since threshold values for the food criteria have not yet been set, reference is sometimes made to the assessments for the individual species groups under descriptor 1. Whether good environmental condition is achieved for descriptor 4 on the food depends on whether the individual elements of the food network achieve good environmental status. Despite assessments of individual sub-elements of the food network, it is currently not possible to assess whether the food network as a whole will be in good environmental condition by 2020. However, the balance of the sea food is expected to improve as the environmental targets for pressure factors and condition under the other descriptors is obtained. Going forward, therefore, work remains in the regional conventions with the development of relevant indicators and the setting of relevant thresholds. For this, it must be ensured that there is sufficiently good data.
The sea food network is dependent on the state of the different species groups, and since threshold values for the food criteria have not yet been set, reference is sometimes made to the assessments for the individual species groups under descriptor 1. Whether good environmental condition is achieved for descriptor 4 on the food depends on whether the individual elements of the food network achieve good environmental status. Despite assessments of individual sub-elements of the food network, it is currently not possible to assess whether the food network as a whole will be in good environmental condition by 2020. However, the balance of the sea food is expected to improve as the environmental targets for pressure factors and condition under the other descriptors is obtained. Going forward, therefore, work remains in the regional conventions with the development of relevant indicators and the setting of relevant thresholds. For this, it must be ensured that there is sufficiently good data.
The sea food network is dependent on the state of the different species groups, and since threshold values for the food criteria have not yet been set, reference is sometimes made to the assessments for the individual species groups under descriptor 1. Whether good environmental condition is achieved for descriptor 4 on the food depends on whether the individual elements of the food network achieve good environmental status. Despite assessments of individual sub-elements of the food network, it is currently not possible to assess whether the food network as a whole will be in good environmental condition by 2020. However, the balance of the sea food is expected to improve as the environmental targets for pressure factors and condition under the other descriptors is obtained. Going forward, therefore, work remains in the regional conventions with the development of relevant indicators and the setting of relevant thresholds. For this, it must be ensured that there is sufficiently good data.
The sea food network is dependent on the state of the different species groups, and since threshold values for the food criteria have not yet been set, reference is sometimes made to the assessments for the individual species groups under descriptor 1. Whether good environmental condition is achieved for descriptor 4 on the food depends on whether the individual elements of the food network achieve good environmental status. Despite assessments of individual sub-elements of the food network, it is currently not possible to assess whether the food network as a whole will be in good environmental condition by 2020. However, the balance of the sea food is expected to improve as the environmental targets for pressure factors and condition under the other descriptors is obtained. Going forward, therefore, work remains in the regional conventions with the development of relevant indicators and the setting of relevant thresholds. For this, it must be ensured that there is sufficiently good data.
The sea food network is dependent on the state of the different species groups, and since threshold values for the food criteria have not yet been set, reference is sometimes made to the assessments for the individual species groups under descriptor 1. Whether good environmental condition is achieved for descriptor 4 on the food depends on whether the individual elements of the food network achieve good environmental status. Despite assessments of individual sub-elements of the food network, it is currently not possible to assess whether the food network as a whole will be in good environmental condition by 2020. However, the balance of the sea food is expected to improve as the environmental targets for pressure factors and condition under the other descriptors is obtained. Going forward, therefore, work remains in the regional conventions with the development of relevant indicators and the setting of relevant thresholds. For this, it must be ensured that there is sufficiently good data.
The sea food network is dependent on the state of the different species groups, and since threshold values for the food criteria have not yet been set, reference is sometimes made to the assessments for the individual species groups under descriptor 1. Whether good environmental condition is achieved for descriptor 4 on the food depends on whether the individual elements of the food network achieve good environmental status. Despite assessments of individual sub-elements of the food network, it is currently not possible to assess whether the food network as a whole will be in good environmental condition by 2020. However, the balance of the sea food is expected to improve as the environmental targets for pressure factors and condition under the other descriptors is obtained. Going forward, therefore, work remains in the regional conventions with the development of relevant indicators and the setting of relevant thresholds. For this, it must be ensured that there is sufficiently good data.
Assessments period
2012-2018
2012-2018
2012-2018
2012-2018
2012-2018
2012-2018
Related pressures
  • Changes to hydrological conditions
  • Changes to hydrological conditions
  • Changes to hydrological conditions
  • Changes to hydrological conditions
  • Changes to hydrological conditions
  • Changes to hydrological conditions
Related targets
  • DK-T4.1
  • DK-T4.2
  • DK-T4.3
  • DK-T4.1
  • DK-T4.2
  • DK-T4.3
  • DK-T4.1
  • DK-T4.2
  • DK-T4.3
  • DK-T4.1
  • DK-T4.2
  • DK-T4.3
  • DK-T4.1
  • DK-T4.2
  • DK-T4.3
  • DK-T4.1
  • DK-T4.2
  • DK-T4.3

Danish part of Atlantic North Sea from coastline to EEZ. Data covers DK-TOTAL. (DK-TOTAL-part-ANS)

GES component
D4
Feature
Shelf ecosystem
Element
Sub-apex pelagic predators
Element code
TrophicGuildsPredSApexPel
Element code source
Link to other vocabulary or code lists that may be relevant
Element 2
Element 2 code
Element 2 code source
Element source
EU
Criterion
D4C2
Parameter
Other
Parameter other
As reported under D1C2 for birds
Threshold value upper
Threshold value lower
Threshold qualitative
Threshold value source
Threshold value source other
Value achieved upper
Value achieved lower
Value unit
Value unit other
Proportion threshold value
Proportion value achieved
Proportion threshold value unit
Trend
Unknown
Parameter achieved
Unknown
Description parameter
For several of the trophic levels, the state of the individual species within the trophic level is known, but there is insufficient knowledge of the balance across and between the trophic levels. Therefore, regionally coordinated thresholds for the criteria under descriptor 4 are not currently set.
Related indicator
Criteria status
Unknown
Description criteria
For birds, good environmental status corresponds to the assessment under Article 12 of the Birds Protection Directive. Data from the recent report (2013) of breeding birds shows that, in general, certain species groups are stable or progressive, such as herbivores and birds foraging in the water column. For groups such as waders and birds foraging in the surface, less than 75% of the species are stable or in progress. For wintering birds, most of the species groups are stable, progressive or fluctuating, but not birds that seek food on the seabed.
Element status
Unknown
Description element
This description deals with birds that also cross other trophic levels. In 2013, Denmark reported development trends for a number of Danish birds to the EU under Article 12 of the Bird Protection Directive. The assessment covered the entire Danish marine area. Inventory development varies between species. The number of gulls and alfalfa is, for example. overall, with the exception of the splits, the terns are in decline. For wintering birds, it is difficult to describe a uniform trend.
Integration rule type parameter
Not relevant
Integration rule description parameter
Integration has not been applied
Integration rule type criteria
Not relevant
Integration rule description criteria
Integration has not been applied
GES extent threshold
GES extent achieved
GES extent unit
GES achieved
Unknown
Description overall status
The sea food network is dependent on the state of the different species groups, and since threshold values for the food criteria have not yet been set, reference is sometimes made to the assessments for the individual species groups under descriptor 1. Whether good environmental condition is achieved for descriptor 4 on the food depends on whether the individual elements of the food network achieve good environmental status. Despite assessments of individual sub-elements of the food network, it is currently not possible to assess whether the food network as a whole will be in good environmental condition by 2020. However, the balance of the sea food is expected to improve as the environmental targets for pressure factors and condition under the other descriptors is obtained. Going forward, therefore, work remains in the regional conventions with the development of relevant indicators and the setting of relevant thresholds. For this, it must be ensured that there is sufficiently good data.
Assessments period
2012-2018
Related pressures
  • Changes to hydrological conditions
Related targets
  • DK-T4.1
  • DK-T4.2
  • DK-T4.3